Dettagli

  • Ultima Connessione: 2 giorni fa
  • Genere: Donna
  • Località: Where The Cherry Blossoms Fall
  • Contribution Points: 8 LV1
  • Compleanno: May 05
  • Ruoli: VIP
  • Data di Registrazione: novembre 9, 2021
  • Awards Received: Flower Award4

Sakura_Falling

Where The Cherry Blossoms Fall

Sakura_Falling

Where The Cherry Blossoms Fall
Completo
Stalker
1 persone hanno trovato utile questa recensione
feb 10, 2023
14 di 14 episodi visti
Completo 0
Generale 8.0
Storia 8.0
Acting/Cast 8.5
Musica 8.5
Valutazione del Rewatch 7.5
Questa recensione può contenere spoiler

Secretly Crushing On This One

You know the saying, "Don't judge a book by it's cover"? That definitely applies to this drama. I don't think I've ever watched a drama that gave me such conflicting emotions. It is by far the cringiest the drama I have ever watched, the drama that made me talk to my screen the most, and made me suffer the most second hand embarrassment ever. I think I legitimately spent a good half of this drama just hiding my face because I couldn't watch that level of embarrassment unfold in front of me. That being said, this drama also had me in stitches, literally laughing out loud, it made me cry, and underneath all the cringe and embarrassment, is a really beautiful story. In the end, despite my initial uncertainty, I found this drama and its characters have a lot of heart.

The first few episodes were the hardest to get through and where I teetered on whether to keep watching or just drop it. At that point, you haven't really gotten to know the characters yet, so while most of them seem pretty innocuous, Toh comes across as a lot. I understand having a secret crush, I can even kind of understand keeping things associated with your crush though not nearly to the extent he does and definitely not the food items, that was just gross, but his crush went a bit beyond the bounds of comfort me into obsession. I wouldn't call him a stalker as technically the definition of a stalker is someone who harasses another person with unwanted or obsessive attention. In Toh's case, yes, I would say his behavior was obsessive, but he never harassed Nuea or in any way harmed him and Nuea never indicated that the attention was unwanted. Anyway, once I got past those couple of episodes and relationships started developing between Toh and Nuea and Jao and Sky, I became invested.

My absolute favorite thing about this drama though was the way that it broke down society's expectations. Neither Toh or Jao fit society's standards for attractiveness while both Nuea and Sky do. With that in mind, society would not expect them to get together, in fact, as is seen multiple times, society balks at them being together, saying its wrong. Society looks at the surface; beauty and beauty should go together. Nuea and Sky, however, looked under the surface. They saw Toh and Jao for who they were as individuals, not for their looks, and that's what they fell in love with. As someone who doesn't fit society's standards of beauty, I found that powerful. It gives me hope that I can find someone like that someday who will love me exactly as I am. I also loved how neither of them got tired of reminding Toh and Jao that they loved them just as they were. They didn't need to change themselves, they were perfect as is. I also felt like both relationships were good examples of healthy relationships. Nuea and Toh especially had overall good communication. They talked things out like adults for the most part and worked to get past any issues they had. With Sky and Jao, as much as Sky really liked Jao, I appreciated his patience and going at a pace that Jao was comfortable with. To me it showed that he respected his boundaries, especially that scene where they do finally kiss. Sky wanted to kiss him, but he could tell Jao was hesitant and he tells him he can wait. It's not until Jao consents that he kisses him. There's a mutual respect in both relationships that's pretty clear and I just really liked seeing how well it was portrayed.

And that also translated over to characters like Daisy who tried to change himself to be more masculine because he thought that's what Intouch wanted when in fact, Intouch just wanted him to be his badass, feminine self. It also highlighted that changing yourself into someone you're not isn't going to make you happy. Be yourself, there's nothing more beautiful than being confident in your own skin.

The friendship between Toh, Jao, Daisy and Som was a central part of this drama and I loved it. I honestly wish I had friends like that. Their bond is amazing and their unwavering love and support for each other is definitely one of the highlights of this drama. No matter what happens, they are there for each other. I also really liked Nuea and Sky's group of friends. They didn't have quite the same charisma, but they were obviously good people and it was always entertaining when both groups got together.

I absolutely recommend giving this drama a shot. Don't let the cringe and second hand embarrassment factors turn you off. Look past that and focus on the friendships, on the actual story, the characters, it's absolutely worth sticking it out.

Leggi di Più

Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Completo
Like in the Movies
1 persone hanno trovato utile questa recensione
feb 7, 2023
8 di 8 episodi visti
Completo 0
Generale 10
Storia 10
Acting/Cast 10
Musica 10
Valutazione del Rewatch 10
Questa recensione può contenere spoiler

Raw and Real

I will be the first person to say I enjoy BLs. I tend to watch Thai BLs which are generally cute and fluffy and easy to watch. Bonus are the few that have genuinely good messages and ideals. They also tend to be full of tropes and there are a fair number of them that have problematic ideals or are just problematic in general. This drama, however, doesn't just break that mold, it shatters into a million pieces. This is what BLs should aspire to be.

With Karl and Vlad, we get two very different perspectives of their sexuality and identity which is what the story focuses on.
-Vlad has known he's gay from a very young age whereas Karl has never had the freedom to really explore his sexuality or identity until he spends the semester break on his own. And for each of them, its a different journey. Vlad blamed the fact that he was gay for his father's leaving the family. He felt that he had failed in his purpose to save his parent's marriage. He thought his mother was ashamed of him being gay. It was a hard journey for him to become comfortable with himself and find pride in his identity and sexuality and once he did, he wasn't willing to go back into hiding, and rightly so. He's come to a point where he's not only proud of who he is, but he's able to educate others. When Karl flounders, dancing around the word "gay", telling Vlad that he doesn't look gay, rather than getting angry or defensive, Vlad gently corrects and guides him and Karl learns.
-For Karl, he's been living his deceased older brother's life for his entire life instead of living the life he wants, studying architecture instead of film like he wants. Fear rules his life, fear of telling his parents that he wants to transfer majors, fear of his feelings for Vlad, fear of his own sexuality, fear of what others will think, fear of the outside world. This drama highlights just how incredibly hard it truly is for someone to come out. Its not all sunshine and roses, even when they know the people around them will support them, coming to terms that their sexuality and identity does not match what society deems as "normal", that they are faced with telling family and friends who may or may not be supportive, that has to be terrifying. And I feel like they portrayed that so realistically here. But Karl does start facing his fears, little by little, first by telling his parents that he does want to transfer majors and then at the end, with Anna's encouragement, by going out into the world.
What this drama also highlights is the struggle of relationships where one person is out and the other is not. Despite their love for each other, Vlad and Karl are faced with a situation where Vlad is out and he is, understandably, not willing to go back to hiding his sexuality and Karl is still discovering himself and isn't quite ready to take that step. The scene there towards the end in the condo is bittersweet because of that discrepancy. But the open ending of them together watching the movie outside the condo in the open gives me hope that things will work out for them.

I loved our two female characters of Anna and Judit. BLs tend to do female characters dirty either by using them as objects, fangirls for the leads, or villains to cause conflict. Not the case here. They were both well developed characters with their own stories and reasons behind their actions.
-I honestly wasn't sure if I was going to like Judit at first. Her over the top behaviour and constant line that she was an ally seemed very fake. I didn't think she was a bad person, I just didn't really believe her to be as supportive as she said she was. But when she and Vlad had dinner together and he calls her out and everything unfolds, it suddenly all made sense why she acted the way she did. For the first time, he made her face her actions, the damage that her words had caused, and she finally apologized and she admitted that she was still learning too. It was a really great moment between the two of them. What I also appreciated about her character was that even though they had that conversation, Judit was still Judit, there was no immediate change, she was still over the top, she was still spouting her, "I'm an ally" spiel, which I found realistic. Change takes time. She'll get there eventually.
-For Anna, I also found her to be realistic. If a woman has kids, she's expected to be a mother 24/7, 365 days a year and if she takes a break, for some reason, that's looked down on. That is such a damaging concept, and I loved that Anna realized that she needed a break from mothering and she took it. Her comment that she didn't want to blame her daughter was so powerful. Mothers are human beings too, they needs breaks, they need time to themselves and there should be no shame in taking that time. I think she highlights the fact that just because you become a mother, that does not mean your life is over, you can still have your own hopes and dreams and strive for them. And in doing so. she is being a role model for her daughter to never give up. She was just such an amazing character to me and I loved her.
As a side note, although she wasn't a big character, I also really liked Sue. She was always supportive of Vlad and was someone he could really talk to. She gave it to him straight and was pretty no nonsense which I appreciated.

My favorite dramas are the ones that are like puzzles. You have all these pieces, actions or items that you don't think much of, that end up being part of a bigger picture and in the end everything come together like a puzzle. This was one of those dramas. Things like Vlad not liking his hair touched , the corpse in the closet story and then Vlad finding the picture of Karl's deceased brother in the closet, Vlad having a keychain that was a match to Karl's, there was just so much symbolism, so many little moments that turned out to have a bigger impact, it was fantastically brilliant.

The OST can make or break a drama for me. Music is what brings it all together, makes you feel more deeply, immerses you in the moment. The OST for Like in the Movies was flawless. I loved it. Each song was perfect for the scene it was used for and the lyrics too just fit so beautifully.

Literally everything about this drama was just so well thought out. The credits scenes were absolutely genius. I loved how they showed the progression of their relationship each episode. It was perfect. And the icing on the cake was the quote at the end of each episode. Each one was clearly carefully chosen and I looked forward to seeing them.

This was truly such a beautiful drama. I loved every second of the emotional journey it sent me on. I laughed and cried and came to love each and every one of the characters. I cannot recommend it enough.

Leggi di Più

Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Completo
New Life Begins
1 persone hanno trovato utile questa recensione
gen 15, 2023
40 di 40 episodi visti
Completo 0
Generale 9.0
Storia 9.0
Acting/Cast 9.5
Musica 9.0
Valutazione del Rewatch 9.0
Questa recensione può contenere spoiler

Light and Sweet

Starting out watching this drama, I thought it was going to be a your typical lighthearted romcom with the usual palace intrigue, brothers sabotaging brothers, etc. What I was not expecting in the slightest was the level of character development that occurred in nearly every character, touching on mental health particularly postpartum depression, and a focus on women's rights. While unexpected, they added an element of interest that helped to keep me invested in the story.

Despite touching on some more serious topics, the story is overall fairly lighthearted. It is a romcom after all. There are certainly some darker moments, our main characters have their share of problems, some more serious than others, but the issue with romcoms is, you already know the outcome, so those problems seem fairly superficial when you know happily ever after is waiting at the end. That being said, it was still very enjoyable to watch, it just didn't feel like anything was truly at stake. In terms of pacing, while it did have a few episodes where it started to drag a bit, overall it maintained its momentum quite well. The general lack of sabotage and infighting between women in this drama was both surprising and welcoming. Instead, you had women cultivating friendships and banding together to start businesses and better themselves and other women. Similarly, while you often have brothers at each others throats in dramas like this, there was less of that here. All in all, it was quite refreshing.

The acting was superb all around, but Tian Xi Wei absolutely carried the drama. She was simply perfect as Li Wei. Bai Jing Ting was also phenomenal as Yin Zheng. They had such great chemistry together.

What I loved most about this drama was the characters and the fact that nearly every character, whether protagonist or antagonist, had some level of character development. I also appreciated that in the end, there really wasn't a villain per se. Yin Song and Yin Jun both filled that role temporarily, but in the end, neither was really evil. Yin Song was such an interesting, complex character, the "caged bird". He was a complete jerk, and he deserved everything he got, but at the same time, I also pitied him. I appreciated the change in him as he was exiled and respected his decision to live his own way. Yin Jun was greedy, but again, ultimately not evil. While I didn't like him or his wife, there was a part of me that thought their relationship was sweet, even if they were crappy people. I was glad that they also decided to turn over a new leaf though. Other characters I particularly enjoyed were Fangru, particularly seeing her relationship with Hao Jia develop from enemies to allies to friends, Hao Jia herself, seeing her come into her own and learn she didn't need a man, and Li Wei, of course, as she transformed from a country girl into a lady but never lost her sparkle. There really wasn't a character that I disliked in this drama, aside from the 10th prince who was incredibly annoying, and I truly enjoyed watching them all grow and change.

In terms of couples, Li Wei and Yin Zheng reign supreme, obviously. While their romance is definitely a slow burn, it is also very organic. And once they do figure out their feelings for each other, their love is just so sweet. SiSi and Yin Yan are my second favorite couple. Although they have significantly less screen time than most of the other couples and characters, they're just so cute together. I honestly would have liked to have seen more of them. Shanggu and Yin Qi are my least favorite. While on the one hand I do like them together, on the other hand, I don't necessarily love the abusive nature of their relationship. I also got a bit tired of their back and forth of will they, won't they get together.

While the focus on women's rights and mental health was both interesting and welcoming, it was also a bit jarring. Given the historical setting, fictional though it may be, the message itself is very much a contemporary one and there were times when it very much stood out as such. The intent was good, the execution needed some work. I also think the concept was rushed towards the end. Xin state went from not allowing women to do business to suddenly they're going to allow women to be officials? That was done far too abruptly and without enough context to make it believable. Again, the execution needed work.

The OST was overall quite good. The songs typically fit well the mood and scene. Costuming was gorgeous. I liked how each character had their own distinct style. The cinematography was also very well done.

Ultimately I found this drama to be quite enjoyable. It was sweet and it was lighthearted with just a sprinkling of seriousness to add some more interest. It's one that I would definitely recommend watching at least once and one that I will likely come back to in the future.

Leggi di Più

Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Completo
Manner of Death
1 persone hanno trovato utile questa recensione
lug 26, 2022
14 di 14 episodi visti
Completo 0
Generale 9.0
Storia 8.5
Acting/Cast 9.0
Musica 8.5
Valutazione del Rewatch 8.5
Questa recensione può contenere spoiler

A Refreshing Change

I decided to watch this drama for several reasons. First, I had just finished Together With Me: The Next Chapter and while I didn't love that drama, I did enjoy Max and Tul's chemistry and acting and was curious about how they would be in a very different setting. Second, as cute as the typical college Thai BL's are, I wanted a change and something more mature and with more substance. Since I've always enjoyed crime dramas, this seemed like it might fit the bill. Overall, I would say it did. While I felt the story was at times a little more complicated and convoluted than was strictly necessarily, I did very much enjoy it.

This drama had a lot more depth and covered far more territory than I could have every expected. I wasn't expecting a light and fluffy romance, but I also wasn't expecting some of the dark territory it explored. The subjects of rape, human trafficking, and drug dealing play heavily in the story. The romance, while certainly present, is not necessarily the main focus which I found refreshing. Don't get me wrong, I love a good romance, but having a plot that was overall well thought out and executed and having more depth than just gratuitous kissing scenes was a very nice change. I liked that the show played their hand of who was the actual murderer pretty close to the chest. While I had my suspicions, I was never 100% certain until the actual killer was revealed.

The characterization was overwhelmingly good. Despite a relatively large cast, everyone had their place and their story though there were certainly a few missteps or a few things lacking, the characters were, for the most part, well-rounded which I was truly impressed with. I came for Max and Tul to see how they acted together in a more mature setting and they did not disappoint. I very much prefer their relationship here to that portrayed in Together With Me. I enjoyed the maturity and the vulnerability they both displayed. Their acting together and apart was on point and was definitely a highlight for me.

The themes of the drama were more complex and varied than in most BL's which I also appreciated. The prevailing one to me was that not everyone is as they seem, even if you think you know them. Bun really represented this as he realized the people he was closest to were not at all who he thought they were. Part of what I love about his character is his determination and focus to find the truth no matter the cost. Even after discovering people he knew and trusted were involved, he maintained his purpose of seeing justice delivered. Another theme is that we often have no idea what other people are suffering. Jane, Tan, Natty, and Nam had all suffered either in the past or present, but very few people if anyone knew the true extent of their suffering. I think it really highlighted how common that is, how most people do conceal their pain and sometimes by the time they find the courage or have the ability to speak out about it, it may be too late.

I was surprised at the noticeable lack of any kind of OST. I did like the intro music with the credits. I thought it fit well with the mystery of the drama.

I really didn't have too many issues with this drama. As with any drama, there were certainly some misses, but nothing that I felt negated the good. The pacing as with a lot of Thai BL dramas was hit or miss. Some things were sped up that it would have been nice to have more time to process and other parts were dragged out that could have been skimmed over more. One of my biggest issues was the speed with which anyone injured healed. Shot? Up in a couple days. Beaten almost to death? Walk it off the next day. I understand that due to pacing they couldn't have characters laid up in bed all the time, but it seems like they could have changed something to make it a bit more believable. There were also a few instances where characters were very conveniently in the right place at the right time that stretched belief.

I found this series to be very enjoyable and a very pleasant diversion from the usual. The story was engaging and intriguing and the acting and characters were almost universally fantastic. I'm very much looking forward to season 2 and I will certainly be watching this one again in the future!

Leggi di Più

Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Completo
Colore Rush
1 persone hanno trovato utile questa recensione
mar 31, 2022
8 di 8 episodi visti
Completo 0
Generale 7.0
Storia 7.5
Acting/Cast 7.0
Musica 8.5
Valutazione del Rewatch 6.5

Short and Sweet

The good and bad thing about Korean BLs is that they are almost universally short and sweet, easily consumed in a few hours. And while typically a very pleasant diversion, they are often lacking when it comes to fleshing out the story, having fully developed characters, and wrapping up the story neatly. This drama suffered from all three issues, but I still very much enjoyed it.

Pros:
- The acting was overall quite solid I felt. Yoo Jun was definitely a stand out and the most consistent. He perfectly showcased his character's inner turmoil and I really appreciated how much emotion he managed to convey just with his eyes. His chemistry with Hyun Jun was also quite good and they played off of each other well except when it came to kissing. That was painful to watch. Hyun Jun was pretty good, though he seemed to struggle with some of the more serious scenes where he came off almost robotic at times. He did much better portraying Yoo Han's mischievous, cheeky side. Seo Hoo and Hyo Gi had smaller roles but were also quite fun and I enjoyed their addition.
- In terms of the story, there are both pros and cons to this aspect but for the pros, I found the world created absolutely fascinating with this concept of monos and their probes and I honestly would have loved it if it had been explored more in depth. This drama had some great scenes, but one of my favorites was when Yoo Han asked Yeon Woo to teach him the colors he saw. It was such a sad, but poignant scene and I thought it was done beautifully. I also appreciated the reveal of Yoo Han's condition at the end, that both boys were struggling with their obsession for the other, it wasn't just Yeon Woo, and how neither could bear to let the other go. Very interesting and overall well done on that front. The mix of dark and light, particularly towards the end was interesting and added some spice to things. There were some twists that I was not expecting but were handled quite well. The romance developed organically more or less and the dangling question of whether it was truly love or obsession made it more interesting.
- The OST was fantastic. The opening in song in particular really caught my attention and has already been added to my Spotify playlist.
- I really loved the media arts scene. It was a stand out for me just in terms of seeing the characters' development as well as just being a visual treat. Loved it. I also found the way they showed the color rush to be appealing. It's not what I was expecting but I found it to be quite beautiful and well done. I also appreciated the way they switched between how the rest of the world saw things with color and how Yeon Woo saw the world.

Cons:
- With the story, as I said before, there were both pros and cons. One of the cons is the world, which I loved, but I did feel needed a bit more exploration. I really wanted more info on the monos and probes to better be able to understand them. Another was the characterization. Considering the shortness of the drama, they did a good job of introducing the characters and giving enough background to keep them interesting, but, again, I wanted more, especially when it came to Yoo Han. I felt like, despite him being the second lead, we found out next to nothing about him and his life except at the very end and even that was pretty minimal. However, my biggest con in this regard is how the mystery of Yeon Woo's mother's disappearance just ended up on the wayside. There were a few other little side plots and such that were also neglected, but I felt that was the biggest one. I honestly got invested in her disappearance and thought the drama was going to be more of a mystery/crime type deal with the boys teaming up to find out what happened to her, but that didn't happen. In fact, we're left exactly where we started and I found that to be more than a tad disappointing. I know there's a Color Rush 2 that I've heard answers the question of what happened to her, so I may check that out, though the apparent of absence of Hyun Jun makes me a little leery of it.

And honestly that is my one con: the storytelling and the plot holes. I truly wish they had made this into a longer, more fleshed out drama because it had so much potential. It's good as a romance but I feel like it could have been much more than that. I wouldn't have objected in the slightest if the mystery of his mother's disappearance and learning more about the monos had been more of a focal point than the romance. That being said, it's a solid romantic story in terms of their developing relationship and I very much enjoyed it. Overall, it is absolutely worth the couple hours it will take you to watch and, due to its shortness, I would not object to watching it again at some point.

Leggi di Più

Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Completo
The Untamed
1 persone hanno trovato utile questa recensione
gen 10, 2022
50 di 50 episodi visti
Completo 0
Generale 9.0
Storia 9.0
Acting/Cast 9.0
Musica 8.0
Valutazione del Rewatch 9.0

Not a Masterpiece, but Worth A Watch

Chinese dramas are always very hit or miss for me. I will oftentimes start out liking a drama but then the plot severely lags in the middle and I lose interest and drop it. Not the case with The Untamed. While the beginning was a bit weak, once the story jumped to the past and became more linear, I found myself hooked.

And there is my first issue with this drama. I have never been a fan of dramas that start in the present and then jump to the past. It's messy and confusing. You don't know who anyone is or why you should care about them and the events that transpired previously. Inevitably you get to the end of the show and have to go back and watch those episodes to see what you missed. In the case of The Untamed, there's a lot missed simply because you don't know the backstory. I think the drama would have been stronger if they just started out sixteen years ago and then jumped to the present.

In terms of acting, it was very hit or miss. I don't think any of the actors gave a truly amazing performance, but there were some that were stronger than others. Xiao Zhan as Wei Wuxian and Wang Yi Bo Lan Wangji both deliver relatively strong performances. In Wang Yi Bo's case, I felt that he took a little longer to settle into his character but once he did, he was overall good. His use of micro expressions to give depth and emotion to his stone faced character was pleasant to see. Xiao Zhan was a little bit one note at times but overall I felt he gave a nuanced performance. Their chemistry together was on point and depending on personal preference, you really could take their relationship as just friendship or something more. Yu Bin was also quite good as Wen Ning and did a good job of vacillating between Wen Ning as a sweet, innocent man and as someone possessed/controlled. Also a shout out to Chen Zhuo Xuan as A-Qing. She had a small role but I really enjoyed her performance and thought she nailed it.
Of less note were Wang Zhuo Cheng as Jiang Cheng, Xuan Lu as Yan Li, and Meng Zi Yi as Wen Qing. Wang Zhuo Cheng had some good moments but overall his performance just wasn't particularly interesting and his expressions lacked the variation that I think the role required not to mention times where his expression just seemed completely wrong for what was going on. And don't get me started on how terribly fake his crying looked. Xuan Lu and Meng Zi Yi suffered from similar problems. Neither one had much variation in their expressions and while it worked better for Meng Zi Yi's character, it just made Xuan Lu's character seem boring. There just wasn't much depth to her so I can't say that I really felt anything despite all that happens to her. Meng Zi Yi had some strong moments, but she was almost too stoic and it didn't allow the audience to really get to know her or her character as well as if she'd been a bit more emotive. That being said, I did find her character to be more interesting than Yan Li's.

The OST was also a bit hit or miss. At times, I absolutely loved it, although it could be repetitive. But the combination of the string and woodwind instruments was quite beautiful and I did enjoy the cues with those in them. Other times, particularly during the battle at Nightless City, it just seemed so completely off. I truly don't know who decided that music fit the scene but it was awful and really pulled me out of the moment. There were a few other instances where the music just didn't work but that one was the worst.

In terms of the directing and visuals, I found them to be very repetitive. I don't know how many times we got shots of men gripping their swords or monsters throwing their heads back and roaring, for example, but it was a lot. For me, they were distracting and eventually just got annoying, especially when you got several of them almost back to back in one scene. Like, we get it, he's mad, moving on now. The special effects were also lacking, but that's not terribly unusual for these dramas. In particular though, there's a scene with a wolf that is just painful because its so incredibly fake. And, as with a fair number of other dramas I've watched, the plot twist wasn't so much of a plot twist because there were so many hints given beforehand. When the guy is smirking evilly behind everyone's back, its a pretty good guess that he's a bad guy and up to no good. It would have made the story so much stronger if they hadn't shown that, because it probably would have been an actual shock that he was the villain. But oh well. As with most fantasy/historical dramas, I did like the costuming, particularly Wei Wuxian and Lan Wanji's. The general color of their costumes remained the same throughout, but the use of different fabrics and embroidery and slight variations in color made them more interesting. The wigs, as with most dramas, were pretty fake looking, some were better than others, but I wouldn't call them great. Many of the props were also quite fake looking, the swords in particular caught my attention. Real swords do not bend and wobble like the ones in the drama do.

Overall, despite its flaws, this was an entertaining and engaging drama. This is not a drama that you should closely analyze. If you want to really enjoy it, just go with it, don't overanalyze any part of it or it does start to fall apart a bit and you notice various holes and inconsistencies and unanswered questions. Just enjoy it as is and its a great romp. I think the lack of a central romance did it a huge favor. Instead focusing on Wuxian and Wangji's growing respect for each other and friendship allowed the story to keep moving and remain more fluid than many other dramas I've watched. Again, as a side note, if you want to view it as a gay love story, you certainly can though there is nothing explicit, not even a hug, but there are lingering glances and facial expressions that you can absolutely read as expressing unspoken romantic feelings. However, all of that is more background and, again, not the central focus. The mystery of whodunnit was fun and interesting and overall well done. Again, definitely some flaws, but just go with it. While you can figure out most of it before the big reveal, there were a few aspects that were truly surprising. Is it a masterpiece? In my opinion, no. But it is one of the strongest Chinese dramas I've ever seen in a while and its one that I will absolutely watch again in the future.

Leggi di Più

Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Completo
Don't Say No Special
1 persone hanno trovato utile questa recensione
nov 12, 2021
1 di 1 episodi visti
Completo 0
Generale 7.0
Storia 6.0
Acting/Cast 10
Musica 8.0
Valutazione del Rewatch 5.0
Questa recensione può contenere spoiler

Cute but Doesn't Add Much

Like others, coming into this I was hoping for a resolution to Leon and Pob's story. I really enjoyed watching their relationship develop in Don't Say No and was disappointed that they didn't end up together though I appreciated the reasoning of it and was glad it wasn't something stupid that separated them. However, I ended up disappointed in this aspect. Though they are both in the special, they don't interact with each other at all, just multiple instances of barely missing each other, and their screen time is very limited. Here the reasoning for their continued separation is more than a little pathetic. Pob emailed Leon multiple times over those three years but Leon never replied and then talks about having lost the password for the email account a year ago. It didn't make much sense especially when password recovery is far from rocket science. There's a part of me that's hoping there will be another series dedicated to their relationship and this was a bit of a teaser for that. I hate seeing their story left unfinished.
In regards to the plot, well, there really isn't one. Despite the three year jump, there's no story progression. Leo and Fiat return to Thailand after studying abroad and basically just spend time with their friends before Leo starts his new job. There are some very sweet moments as well as one rather smoldering scene, but again, not a whole lot happening. I did appreciate the subtle changes in their characters though. They're still the same people but there is a greater maturity to both of them, especially Fiat. Their open communication and the little things they say show that both they and their relationship have continued to develop in healthy ways. I've watched several dramas where couples talk about their need to communicate and make positive changes that never happen so actually seeing that change was very refreshing. Their friends, on the other hand, are pretty much hilariously unchanged.
In conclusion, I wouldn't call watching it a waste of time, its short and sweet, a lighthearted escape back into well-loved character's lives, but if you're looking for any major changes in those lives or a larger continuation of their story, I'm afraid you'll be disappointed.

Leggi di Più

Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Completo
Step by Step
1 persone hanno trovato utile questa recensione
lug 15, 2023
12 di 12 episodi visti
Completo 0
Generale 7.5
Storia 7.0
Acting/Cast 8.5
Musica 7.5
Valutazione del Rewatch 7.5
Questa recensione può contenere spoiler

One Step At A Time

Step By Step is one of those dramas that I feel you either love it or hate it. I found it to be different from most standard BLs with it's office setting and focusing on the office dynamics and work relationships as well as the romantic ones. It was initially pleasant that the leads' relationship wasn't rushed and had time to develop, but I do feel that it lost it's way towards the end. It's not a perfect drama by any means, it didn't always seem to know what to do with it's side characters, there were plot lines that popped up out of nowhere and others that were simply ghosted, there weren't always good explanations for why characters reacted the way that they did, etc. Still, I personally enjoyed it and thought it was a pleasant diversion.

The plot is nothing fancy, essentially an office romance between a boss and his subordinate, which of course is going to cause drama. What I liked about it though was the attention to detail in regards to that office setting. We actually get to see the characters working, going to meetings, presenting, and so on. Maybe because I'm at the ripe age of 32, I didn't find it boring, but I can understand those who did. Personally it felt like a slice of life drama with an office focus, but more realistic than others I've seen. Yes, there's the ridiculous and over the top moments and things that would never happen in actual office, but I enjoyed that quality of peeking into a world I'm not at all familiar with fictional though it may be. It did feel like the story started to lose steam a little over halfway through and didn't seem to know where to go from there. And then there at the end there was a lot of drama thrown in which, besides being unnecessary, felt rushed. And I have to say that the ending, while cute, was rather anti-climatic. Despite it's length, it still felt like there were unanswered questions.

The pacing was a mess. Most of the drama and actual issues with our leads' relationship were relegated to the last three episodes and that's because they didn't actually get together until Episode 10. I have no issues with a slow burn which this definitely was, but I think the story could have been better spread out, allowing them to get together sooner and actually have some time as a couple before the drama started and then showing them handling those issues as a couple or delving into their characters more to show why things ended between them the way that they did prior to the time jump. Time in general was a struggle with this drama as it was hard to tell how much time had passed. It didn't feel like much time had passed, but then things like Ae's pregnancy would make me realize that a lot more time had gone by than I thought. Especially in an office setting, it felt like they should have been able to more clearly show that time progression. There was also the issue with the side couples/story lines not getting the attention they deserved which, again, could have been rectified if the pacing and story planning had been better. As it was, we were left with a very unsatisfying ending for Jaab and Jen who essentially just disappeared as the story progressed, Ae, Khanun and Beam were also shuffled off to the side and only showed up on occasion after a while, Chot and his boyfriend were thrown in at random times, and there were other parts that just needed better planning.

One of the biggest things I felt was lacking was insight into the characters' thoughts and the reasoning behind their reactions. Two examples would be Jaab's sudden rejection of Jane and Pat's reaction to finding out Jeng was gay. Jane was a fairly minor character throughout the series, so I can understand to an extent not going in depth with his emotions and mental state, but given that we are given the impression that he is in a happy, committed relationship, I do think there needed to be more insight into why he was so swayed by Jaab. With Jaab, he's liked Jane for a while, so why when Jane reveals that he and his boyfriend broke up, does he say they should just be friends? They shared a kiss, it was obvious Jaab still had feelings for Jane so what was with that? There was no explanation, no reasoning, nothing as to why he didn't want to give a relationship with Jane a shot. Similarly, Pat's reaction to finding out Jeng was gay seemed over the top and unnecessary. Why was he so shocked and put off by that revelation? Pat's reactions to things involving Jeng didn't always make sense, but this one and his decision to ghost Jeng for two years felt like taking things to the extreme. There needed to be more explanation as to why Pat reacted the way that he did for me to understand and sympathize with him.

The characters ranged from good to mediocre. There were a couple of gems in there, but most of them didn't leave much, if any, of an impression. Overall, I found the way characters were treated to be a bit disappointing just because it was so all over the place. Some characters had great character development and others were left stagnant.
-Pat was definitely more on the mediocre side for me. His childishness, tantrums and changeability made him a hard character for me to really get on board with. More insight into his character, why he was the way that he was, would have been helpful. As it stands, he really did just come across as immature and there were times that I really struggled to understand what Jeng saw him in aside from that he is a cute kid. Jeng talked about how smart he was and that's something that should have been shown and utilized more because while he did seem intelligent, it didn't seem like he was extraordinarily so. There also needed to be more insight into his feelings for Jeng. While initially he was obviously attracted to Jeng before realizing that he was his boss, once that revelation came about, his interest seemed to cool. Afterwards, there were a few hints that maybe he was developing feelings for Jeng, but when he went back to Put, it put those feelings in question. Regarding Put, that conflict felt like it resolved far too quickly. We went from Pat not wanting to see him, speak to him, anything, to, what felt like in a very short time span, being willing to start a relationship with him again. And then Pat goes from crying over their breakup to confessing he has feelings for Jeng. I almost felt like I had whiplash with the way Pat's feelings seemed to keep jumping around. I also wanted to explore more as to why Pat didn't believe that Jeng's feelings for him were real and why he didn't feel like he deserved Jeng initially. I was frankly a bit disappointed in Pat's character growth. He talks at one point about he's grown so much and is no longer as emotional, but I didn't really see that a whole lot. He still seemed overemotional and overreactive to the end.
-Jeng was definitely one of the best characters. He was very interesting to watch, especially as his feelings for Pat developed which I felt was well done. His feelings were clearly built up, starting from polite interest which then grew into romantic feelings. There was never any doubt regarding his feelings for Pat. I wish they had done as well with Pat and his feelings. I also appreciated his character growth from no nonsense, perfectionist boss to someone who was able to let loose a bit. Part of what also appealing about him was that he wanted to change for the better and he made an effort to do so. There's the element that Pat did inspire those changes, but he made the conscious decision to change on his own. His maturity especially in contrast to Pat was refreshing especially when it came to things like Pat blaming him for essentially not being a mind reader. Pat seemed to think that he should be able to change with a snap of his fingers, not realizing that change does take time, and I was very impressed with Jeng's patience. I would have liked a little more time spent on his background and his relationship with his parents, especially his father. A lot of that was just skimmed over and there at the end, it didn't really feel like things had been resolved between him and his father. Still, I felt that he was overall a decently well-rounded character and I really liked him.
-I didn't have particularly strong feelings about most of the remaining characters save for a few. I found Jaab to be a weird combination of interesting and boring. He had moments where I was invested in him, but there were a lot of other moments where I almost wanted to skip his scenes because he wasn't doing anything for me. Once his relationship with Jane petered out, I really lost interest in him. I did like some of his interactions with Jeng though and the support he was willing to provide eventually. Jane could have been a much better character if he was fleshed out more. As it was, there just wasn't much too him and that made it difficult to relate to him or really feel anything strongly about his character. I was disappointed with that because I did like his relationship with Jaab and I wanted to see more of it's development. I really liked Ae and I wish there had been a bit more of her. Her confidence was awesome as was her obvious love for her friends. She was always ready to go to bat for them and she was just in general an awesome character. I like strong female characters and I feel like they tend to be lacking in a lot of BLs so she was a pleasant surprise. I did find the revelation that Beam had been in love with her to be a bit out of the blue since I hadn't gotten that impression earlier on and it just felt unnecessary. Chot was another gem, I loved that he had a well balanced personality. He had just the right amount of over the top without it being grating. Plus he was just a sweetheart in general, always there to listen and be supportive, an understanding friend and lover, and just an all around lovely person. I could use someone like him in my life. The last character I want to mention is Jeng's father. He was too much of an enigma for me to really appreciate his character and he definitely needed a bit more fleshing out. His actions and thought process were left very ambiguous which works sometimes, but not here. I wanted to understand his treatment of Jeng and Pat as it felt more than a disapproval of his son being gay and getting involved with one of his subordinates.

As for the acting, can I just start off by saying how refreshing it was to see them cast an age appropriate actor for Jeng's role. I couldn't help but thinking about like Moonlight Chicken and how they tried to convince us that Earth could pass for an almost 40 year old. Hair, makeup and clothes can only go so far and trying to make actors look and act older than they are really does not work. Man was perfect because he both looked and acted the part. He gave a certain maturity to the role that someone much younger simply can't. I enjoyed the nuance of his performance and thought he played the part perfectly. This was Ben's first acting role and it showed. He wasn't bad per se, just compared to Man, he felt green. His expressions didn't vary a whole lot and some of the emotional scenes felt forced. I do think if he'd had more experience, he could have better conveyed some of the emotions and thought processes of his character. I was pleased that they cast two actors who are clearly comfortable speaking English since the fluency matched both of their backstories. I've seen far too many dramas where they give their characters backstories of having grown up in the US or spent a lot of time there and are supposed to be fluent, but the actor is clearly not comfortable with the language. I completely understand that learning another language is a challenge, so no disrespect to those actors, it just personally pulls me out of the story when it's clear that they're not as comfortable with the language as the story is trying to make them seen. Both Man and Ben were articulate and clearly understandable and delivered their lines effortlessly.

Despite it's flaws, I overall enjoyed Step By Step. It's not perfect by any means and could have been better with some tweaks, but for what it is, I found it entertaining for the most part. The build up of the characters' relationship, the setting, and the characters themselves had a different feel from other BLs I've watched recently and I liked that. It felt distinctive in it's own way. As I said before, I think this drama is rather polarizing in that you will either love it or hate it without a whole lot in between. If you go in without any major expectations and understand that it is flawed, I think that can stave off the disappointment that some might feel. For my part, I wouldn't discourage anyone from watching it, just be aware that it's not for everyone.

Leggi di Più

Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Completo
HIStory5: Love in the Future
1 persone hanno trovato utile questa recensione
giu 29, 2023
20 di 20 episodi visti
Completo 0
Generale 5.5
Storia 4.0
Acting/Cast 7.0
Musica 8.0
Valutazione del Rewatch 3.5
Questa recensione può contenere spoiler

No Future Here

This was the third installment of the HIStory series that I've watched (I've also watched Trapped and Close to You) and I have to say that this one did not do it for me. I would sincerely love to know how the script ever passed muster with everything that was left unanswered. It truly boggles my mind. It was filled with plot holes, uninspiring characters, general absurdity, a confusing plot, overused cliches and in the end, it failed to draw me in or really make me care about any of the main characters. This isn't one that I can even say had a promising premise that just went awry. So much about it was lackluster and devoid of inspiration and originality which is a pity.

The plot is unnecessarily complicated to say the least. Ho Bo Wei lives in the year 2000, but somehow on New Years Eve, he rides his bike a different route and suddenly ends up in the year 2023 as Tai Che Ni. It's a weird and confusing premise that is never fully explained. I have to admit that I tapped out for a good bit after that first episode before forcing myself to continue so I may be forgetting things, but I don't recall an explanation ever being given for why he was brought into the future, nor is the soul swap ever in any way explained. So exactly what happened to Ho Bo Wei's body and the original Tai Che Ni is left completely up in the air. He ends up meeting Hai Yi and they eventually fall in love. On the side, you have Lin Huai En who starts a new job at the company that sponsored the orphanage where he was raised and runs into Liang Wen Hsen, the Managing Director. Sparks fly between the two and they fall in love as well at lightspeed. That is the bare bones of the story. It is far more complicated than that, but frankly I don't even know where to start because it's absolutely ridiculous how convoluted they decided to make everything.

Everything has to have a reason and connection. No, Hai Yi is not the lazy bones son of the department store owner, it was all part of a master plan to unveil the misdeeds of his father's former second in command. He and Wen Hsen were never actually at odds, they were always working together, in fact, Wen Hsen in the mysterious Sam that Hai Yi kept contacting throughout the series. And Wen Hsen didn't just happen to fall in love with Huai En, he's been keeping an eye on him since he was at the orphanage which definitely added a creepy undertone to their story once that was revealed. Ho Bo Wei rescued Hai Yi when he got separated from his father as a child and gave him his lucky bracelet. Of course, since then, Hai Yi repeatedly wished on the bracelet to be reunited with the big brother who helped him out and then voila, it happens. So much of it just doesn't flow or make sense, especially the whole master plan with Wen Hsen pretending to be corrupt and vying for the chairman position. That was a giant misfire.

And then there were the cliches and general ridiculousness. Of course we have to have the villainous ex-girlfriend cliché. She actually gets multiple uses as she tries to sink her claws into Wen Hsen as well and fails. That was kind of a great scene when he calls Huai En to join them and basically show that he's already taken. Sorry, sweetie. You also have the Hai Yi's father's second in command who practically screams villain. He just needed a villain laugh to complete the image. Adding to the cliches is Wen Hsen's whole sacrificial thing with pretending to be close to Tony because it would be easier if Huai En hated him. Insert eye roll. Tony and the other office workers lock Huai En in cold storage, essentially attempting murder, and absolutely nothing happens to any of them. Wen Hsen yells at Tony a bit, warns him not to bully anyone again and that's that. You can try to kill someone and there will be no consequences in this company apparently. Also the fact that Huae En is left in there for so long that he falls unconscious, but Wen Hsen evidently doesn't take him to the hospital. He's so concerned, but not enough to make sure he received medical attention. Apparently his love is enough to save him.

The characters, oh my goodness, well, they're not boring, I guess. I'm not sure if that's a good thing though?
-Tai Che Ni was such a study in opposites. On the one hand, he could be responsible and mature. On the other hand, he could be so over the top/obnoxious there were times I wanted to suffocate him with a pillow. He's kind of cute but that only gives you so much leeway and as the series progressed, he became less endearing and more annoying. I also struggled with him because of his naivety and the level of self-sabotage with him was so high. He had moments where his instincts were good, but he listened to that twit Se Mo instead and it just made things worse. And then Huai En who actually had a level head on his shoulders would give him advice and he would question him. As for the self-sabotage, I get so sick of characters in BLs just not communicating and this was no exception. Instead of talking to Hai Yi about what was going on, he decided his best options were to create distance between them and then just leave with no warning. I am fairly certain that Hai Yi would get that he was concerned about his grandmother, but his methods were stupid and just caused unnecessary conflict. And I have trouble forgiving him for the fact that not once did he offer any kind of comfort to Hai Yi regarding his father's death. He was so self-absorbed with his antics that he completely failed to be there for him when he needed him most.
-Hai Yi was significantly less obnoxious than Che Ni, but he was also a bit boring. Nice to look at, but not much there. He's basically a big kid in some ways. His father was never there for him, always focused on the company he was building, so he suffers from abandonment issues, something that comes up in his relationship with Che Ni as he's terrified of him leaving and being alone again. I did feel for him though because I felt like he was truly trying in his relationship with Che Ni and I could understand his frustration with Che Ni trying to put distance between them. Hai Yi actually tried to communicate and figure out what was wrong. I liked that he wasn't playing games like waiting till the 20th ring or some other stupid crap. He may not have been the most interesting character, but he was relatively straightforward and I appreciated that.
-Wen Hsen took a bit of a hit for me once they revealed exactly how long he'd been aware of Huai En. The fact that he'd been watching him and sponsoring him for so long, that he'd kind of paved the path for him to be hired and everything, it started to read as a bit creepy to me. I don't think he had any bad intentions, he doesn't use the fact that he has helped Huai En out in any way to curry favor with him, but there's almost an element of grooming there. I think I'm reaching, but their relationship just made me slightly uncomfortable which was disappointing because I found it kind of sweet initially. Some drama was added to him when he was thrown into the race for chairman. Though how anyone could seriously believe he was actually evil, I don't know. His character did become a bit more interesting when it was revealed that he was the Sam that Hai Yi had been communicating with and asking to look into people.
-Huai En is a bit of a bland character. He's sweet, he's one of the smarter characters, if only Che Ni would have listened to him sometimes, but he's just not that interesting. We do get to see some character growth with him, in the office at least. He learns to stand up for himself and not let his coworkers walk all over him. I do like his friendship with Che Ni, their characters actually seem to work together well. His relationship with Wen Hsen develops far too fast to seem remotely natural and I've already mentioned my reservations regarding it, but there is also a certain sweetness to it.
-Se Mo was just annoying. I didn't like her character and I didn't feel that she added anything beneficial. She tried to come across as some kind of love guru but she caused far more problems than she solved. She had a few moments where she was genuinely sweet and helpful but for the most part, I just found her frustrating.
-Fu De was interesting in his many roles. I still don't fully understand what the point of him was, but I did like his character for the most part. If nothing else, he did provide some comic relief.

The acting was a bit stale. Sean Chang plays as a straight guy trying really hard to be gay and it just does not work. There is no chemistry between him and Linus Wang and I lay most of the blame on him. I just could not take him seriously. For this being Linus Wang's first role, I thought he did a serviceable job. He seemed like he was really trying and while he definitely needs some polishing, I think he has potential and I hope to see him again in the future. Anson Chen and Jason Tauh are both good looking men, but I was not feeling the chemistry between them either. They had a few scenes where it felt like maybe there were some sparks, but it just never really took off. They also didn't really seem to connect with their characters. Jason was almost boring as Huai En at times and Anson was very one note with the same expression used repeatedly.

I was not thrilled that the stepbrothers from HIStory 4 were brought back. I generally liked HIStory 4 aside from them but I hated their storyline. The rape and the fact that they were stepbrothers really didn't work for me, and to have them be the ones they brought back instead of Li Cheng and Mu Ren did not sit well with me. It was just very disappointing and kind of killed the ending for me, personally.

This latest release in the HIStory series is the weakest of the ones I've seen. It lacks in so many ways and has so few redeeming qualities that I really don't think it's worth the time or effort to watch it. You're not going to miss anything skipping this one.

Leggi di Più

Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Completo
Chains of Heart
1 persone hanno trovato utile questa recensione
apr 28, 2023
10 di 10 episodi visti
Completo 0
Generale 6.0
Storia 5.0
Acting/Cast 7.5
Musica 7.5
Valutazione del Rewatch 4.0
Questa recensione può contenere spoiler

Don't Chain Yourself To This One

My, oh my was that a trainwreck of epic proportions. I have to wonder with some of the BLs that have been coming out lately if they're written by adolescents because the number of questions that remain unanswered, the plot holes, basically everything about the story is just a complete mess. I mean, does anyone read through the script before they start filming or do they just take it and run with it, no questions asked? Anyway, this drama came off as yet another KinnPorsche knock off. But unlike KinnPorsche which had its charms and was gritty and dark, Chains of Heart was just a confusing mess that didn't seem to know what it wanted be. That's not to say it wasn't entertaining at times, but as a whole, it really didn't work.

The story had potential, it could have been interesting and great. If it had imitated KinnPorsche more and leaned into the dark and gritty, I think it could have worked. But unlike KinnPorsche which overall did a good job of blending that dark and gritty with romance and comedy, Chains of Heart never really found its footing. The comedy fell flat, the romance also fell flat because nearly every part of it was in flashbacks and the mystery of who Lue was kept going far too long preventing the pair from being reunited until almost the very end, and, again, it just failed to really commit to being dark and gritty. It kept adding in new information without answering the questions that had already been asked. And the fact that so much was left unexplained left me feeling frustrated and wanting answers. I mean, first and foremost, how the heck did Ken and Din even survive falling from that cliff? Looking at it, I don't see how they could have possibly survived, especially relatively unscathed. Besides that main question, there were a multitude of others like: What was with Lue's wardrobe? Considering the climate, it made zero sense. Why didn't Din ever attempt to contact Ken until 2 years after the accident? What changed that suddenly he was back? We knew Chief Inpha was involved in drug trafficking and selling wood illegally, but then in the last episode we have organ trafficking and prostitution thrown in as well. What was really the point of that and why was it never addressed before? We already knew he was a bad guy, they didn't need to tack on to that for shock value. And then there are the characters. Din's boss is revealed to be dirty and then he's never seen or mentioned again? How did Inspector Don get involved with Din? He seemed to be loyal to Chief Inpha and then suddenly, nope, he's actually a good guy (?) and is on Din's side? Who exactly was the shady doctor and how did he know Din/get involved in his exploits? There are many more questions and holes, but honestly, this review would be the length of a short novel if I listed them all.

This drama did what a lot of dramas do and revealed events from the past in flashbacks. I am rarely a fan of this technique because it is generally very poorly done and leaves more questions than answers. This was no exception. It was unclear at times how the events shown fell linearly, where they were, and how long ago it actually was. I honestly would have preferred if they had shown the story linearly, starting from when Din and Ken met which wasn't explained well, jumping to the more relevant and important parts of their relationship up until they fall from the cliff and then jumping forward two years. I think it would have been much smoother, would have allowed for more questions to be answered, and generally just made more sense. Even in the present though, it was not clear where events were taking place. For example, there at the beginning, it took me a bit to realize that Ken was not in Thailand but rather in China or maybe Taiwan. I don't think it's ever explicitly stated where he was. And then when he does go back to Thailand, it's never clear where events are taking place other than Bangkok because it's the only city featured.

I have to comment on that final episode because it was the cherry on top of an already messy drama. We had Din who somehow became invulnerable. He's getting shot at from all sides and is basically a sitting target for a few of the baddies, yet not a single one of them can hit him. Then we have him playing hide and seek with them in the forest, doing the whole passing right by them without them noticing. And he takes on five of the bad guys and comes out pretty much unscathed without a drop of blood on him despite slitting several throats. This happens again shortly thereafter when he shoots a guy in the head at point blank range and doesn't get any blood on him. Following this, he and Chief Inpha decide to spontaneously have an old fashioned duel and shoot at each other at the same time. All this while Sia is sitting on Inpha's lap and somehow comes out apparently unhurt. I was a little bit surprised at how Din killed Chief Inpha. He'd tried to kill the man before, but there was something about the way he shot him execution style in the head that felt out of character. The man was incapacitated, his cronies all killed, all Din had to do was wait for the authorities to arrive to arrest him. Instead he murdered him. Perhaps the point was to showcase that Din had changed and become Lue. In a way, Din was dead and in his place was Lue who was more ruthless than Din had been. But I may be giving them too much credit for that. And then that ending. I literally sat up and went WTF?! That's it? That's the ending? An arrest warrant was issued for Din's arrest and then he just disappeared? I don't mind open endings when they're done well, but this was not done well. We spent most of the drama with Ken and Din apart until it is finally confirmed in Episode 9 what I think we all knew by that point, that Lue was actually Din. They get one night together and then are separated again. That's not a satisfying ending, it's lazy and it's baiting the viewers. I've since seen that there's supposed to be a special episode, so maybe that will rectify this colossal error to some small degree.

And then there was the lack of continuity within the drama. The actor's heights was a big one. Boom and Kut play the same character, but there is a noticeable height difference between the two. That difference is one of the main reasons I questioned whether Lue was actually Din because plastic surgery can change a face, but it doesn't alter your height. And the sad thing is, there are simple ways to address that discrepancy and make them appear to be the same height, but apparently that wasn't worth the effort. Lue was also missing the bullet wound from when he was shot by Chief Inpha on the cliff. That missing detail was another major reason I questioned whether he was Din. There were other instances where characters were injured in one scene and the in the next the injury is gone or is significantly reduced. A lot of it was just really basic stuff that would have been easy to fix. The fact that it wasn't just makes the team seem lazy.

The characters were a mixed bag. Frankly, most of them were completely forgettable. Ken spent the majority of his screen time either crying or being choked. The constant crying got old after a while. Din as Lue spent most of his time making moon eyes at Ken and getting teary eyed that Ken was rejecting him (because he doesn't know who you are, idiot!). Personally, I preferred Din. He seemed to be more level-headed and more of a man of action. Something about his personality and character was just more appealing and interesting to me than Lue. Payu and Hin were supposed to be the second couple and also the comedic relief, but they really didn't work for me. I was initially unsure whether the two of them were actually a couple because they didn't really act like one consistently. They had a few lackluster steamy scenes which answered that question, but I found them to be overall pointless characters and singularly unfunny. There was the psychic who popped up randomly and absolutely no questions were answered about him. Like was he truly able to see visions? The rest of Ken and Din's friend group were not memorable and every time they popped up, I couldn't remember who was who. Inpha was about as subtle as a red flag. You could tell he was the villain from the get go which was disappointing and boring. When a show brands itself as a mystery, I want there to be mystery and there really wasn't any in this show. Making Inpha a more nuanced character where his motives and character could be called into question as to whether he was good or evil would have been far more interesting. Itt was kind of interesting at first, but his insane antics and laugh got old fast. And then again, you had characters like Inspector Don who gave no indication of their motivation and why they were doing what they were doing. With essentially every character, there was not enough background information to really understand them. What were their motivations, their feelings, their reasoning? In most cases, none of that was answered and it made the characters feel shallow. I really didn't have strong feelings for any of them because so much was lacking.

As for the acting, I will give kudos to Haii for two things. First, that he, for the most part, was believable with all his crying. I've seen far too many dramas where the actors are fake crying and it's painful to watch. Second, that he was able to build a rapport with both Kut and Boom as they portrayed Din/Lue. He had good chemistry with both of them and they interacted well. I'm sure that was a challenge so kudos to him. Both Boom and Kut did a good job with portraying the same but also not the same character. They were essentially playing two different characters, but there were small similarities between the two that made it believable that they were also playing the same character, if that makes sense. The others were again pretty forgettable. I was disappointed that Kob was relegated to being nothing more than Ken's father. He's a good actor and I wanted him to have more screen time and a more interesting role. He still performed excellently with what he was given, I just wish there'd been more.

The production was really strong in some areas and very weak in others. The cinematography was really beautiful in parts. But the editing at times was choppy. Some of the camera work was shaky. There were also some weird angles that were just awkward and distracting. For the most part, I liked the music. There were a few cues that were really fantastic and really fit with the mood of the scene. The subtitles were a big issue. There were a number of times where what was being said was not subtitled and that really didn't help matters because information was lost.

Despite the fact that this drama was such a total mess, I did enjoy parts of it. The messiness is part of what was entertaining and I found that once I disengaged my brain and stopped trying to make sense of things and instead just went with the flow, it was much more enjoyable. Honestly, I think that's the only way to really watch this drama. A lot of the comedy came from the absurdity of what was going on, like being shot at from all sides and not taking a single hit. The parts that were meant to be comedic weren't all that funny. The ending is disappointing. Do not go into this expecting a happy ending or a good open ending; it's neither of those. This is not a drama I'll watch again. I think watching it again would just raise more questions and cause more frustration. I prefer dramas with a bit more too them and that actually make sense, but if you're one of those people who can disengage their brain and are looking for something moderately entertaining, I would say give it a shot.

Leggi di Più

Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Completo
Coffee Melody
1 persone hanno trovato utile questa recensione
nov 15, 2022
10 di 10 episodi visti
Completo 0
Generale 5.5
Storia 5.5
Acting/Cast 7.0
Musica 5.5
Valutazione del Rewatch 3.5
Questa recensione può contenere spoiler

Misses More Than A Few Notes

I went into this drama excited. It had been a while since I'd watched a BL and the trailer made it look promising. Unfortunately, that was the only thing promising. What I found was a very predictable story, predictable misunderstandings with characters blowing things massively out of proportion, lackluster acting, and bad music. It wasn't the absolute worst BL I've ever seen, but it fell far short of what I had hoped for.

Again the story was predictable and slow. Two guys meet in a coffee shop and fall in love. Nothing new or original here. Plenty of the usual tropes, although the lack of a jealous woman in love with one of the male leads causing problems and homophobic/unsupportive parents was refreshing. The smaller cast helped things move along, although I think some of the other groups waiting to debut at the production company could have been cut to allow more screen time for the main cast. It is still on the slow side though. The conflicts are pretty tame all things considered and there just isn't much for sparks of any kind.

The conflicts between the main couple felt contrived for the most part aside from the first one. I could definitely see both sides of that issue with Plengrak seemingly leading Yi on when not really being ready to actually enter into a relationship and Yi being hurt. I did feel like it was resolved a bit too quickly and the second conflict brought in too quickly afterward. That second conflict was just ridiculous as was Yi's completely unreasonable reaction. He knew what Plengrak's ex had done in the past, knew he was a manipulative jerk and completely overreacted to him kissing Plengrak on the cheek and took off without giving him a chance to explain. Yi had a number of times where he acted pretty immature/overdramatically, but I think this instance takes the cake. And then again, they made up in about a second. Their third and final issue with Yi going abroad was never really much of an issue and was over in about a second since they did a time jump which I hated because it felt like that could have been a good opportunity to actually see them grow as a couple. Also, both their reactions to seeing each other again were very subdued. I'm assuming they visited each other over that year, but seriously, I'd be a little more excited about seeing my boyfriend after not seeing them for an indeterminate amount of time.

As with most Thai BL's, I think there were too many couples. Here part of the problem though was that they seemed to tease them and then forget about them. For example, they seemed to be hinting at Sekram and Tanwa as a possible couple and then suddenly Tanwa has feelings for Yi? And then at the end, they're hinting at Sekram and Tanwa again. Or how Janjao mentions that she and Nawa are finally going to go on a date, but then there's no resolution, no idea how it went or where they're at after the time jump. If you're going to have multiple supporting couples, make sure you have enough screen time to devote to their story or else don't bother. The lack of development is infuriating and this happens in a lot of Thai BL's. Even Thitnuea and Gene's story felt a bit cut off at times though theirs was definitely the best developed after the leads.

The acting was lacking. I wasn't familiar with any of the cast going into this drama so I didn't have any expectations. The only one who really stood out to me was Minty as Janjao. She just felt very present and nailed her character. I adored her. She did a fantastic job showcasing her character's development and she made Janjao real and relatable. I also appreciated how she seemed to really connect with the other actors and bring the best out of them. The rest of the cast wasn't horrible, they just weren't as strong. Benz and Pavel really lacked chemistry to me, I didn't believe in them as a couple and they left me feeling pretty emotionless. Of the two, I found Pavel more interesting to watch. I don't know if it was that he was more expressive or just that Benz's constant cutesiness got very wearing after while.

There's a fair amount I could get into in terms of characterization with each character, but I think I'll pass on that this time. The one thing I will comment on though, is that I think they could have done more with Plengrak's background. He's left as very much a mystery aside from his ex and being best friends with Thitnuea and I would have been interested in knowing more about him. His parents are mentioned but never seen, so are they alive? His ex stole all the money he had saved to open his coffee shop, so how was he able to open his current one considering he's so young? I'm aware these are nitpicky questions, but his family and past were left pretty blank and it left me curious.

I was really excited for the music going into this considering melody is literally in the title, but I found it all very basic and forgettable. The love song that Yi writes get overplayed there towards the end, just over and over again. And it's not a particularly good or catchy song so that got old fast. And what was with "Angels We Have Heard On High" playing at one point? Just some very random song choices going on.

I'm going to mention two things that were very grating. First, Thitnuea's hair got to be very distracting. Throughout the series it was constantly changing from dark pink to light pink, sometime within the same scene. Obviously that's due to the filming schedule, but seriously, continuity is important and it makes the production look lazy and sloppy when they can't be bothered to keep it consistent. Second, for a drama called Coffee Melody, they spent a lot of effort getting the coffee aspect correct, obviously training Pavel and the others how to at least look the part, but Benz? He's supposed to be a famous songwriter, but the few times we hear him play the piano were just painful; it was so obvious he had no idea what he was doing. Again, just made the production look lazy and sloppy to not give him lessons or use one of many tricks to make it look like he's playing when he's not.

The one positive I will give this show is that they nailed the coffee house vibe. To be fair I know nothing about coffee or being a barista but it was believable, that I could go to Thailand and walk into this place and these characters would be there making coffee. I did appreciate that.

I'm sad this drama didn't turn out the way I had hoped. I didn't have incredibly high expectations for it, but I was hoping it would be significantly better than it was. Unfortunately, every part of it was so lackluster it was pretty much doomed to failure from the get go. I don't necessarily regret watching it, but I also have no plans to ever re-watch it and I can't recommend it to anyone either. There are far better BL's out there worthy of your time.

Leggi di Più

Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Completo
Plus & Minus
1 persone hanno trovato utile questa recensione
ago 5, 2022
12 di 12 episodi visti
Completo 1
Generale 5.5
Storia 5.0
Acting/Cast 7.5
Musica 5.0
Valutazione del Rewatch 4.0
Questa recensione può contenere spoiler

So Much Unnecessary Drama

This drama had a lot of potential. The premise, while not groundbreaking, seemed solid. There was a level of interest with the characters being in semi-unique professions: the lead pair as divorce lawyers and the secondary couple as a bartender and laundromat owner respectively. Appearances were refreshingly deceiving in some cases, the character you never thought would be a kick ass fighter actually was. The acting, while not spectacular, was relatively okay considering most of the cast didn't have a ton of experience. And what it seemed like and what I hoped for when the lead couple got together relatively early on was for the rest of the series to focus on them as they settle into their relationship and figure out how to be a couple after having been friends for basically their entire lives. It would have been so delightfully refreshing. Instead, the story gets bogged down with unnecessary angst and an even more unnecessary and contrived break up.

Dramatic break ups are not unusual in any series and while I think its an overused trope, if done well, I don't mind. The break up here though was just so poorly done and so completely nonsensical. Ze Shou's father comes upon he and Li Gong together and isn't instantly supportive. To be perfectly fair, his estranged wife is in the hospital dying from cancer, so I honestly can't blame him for not skipping around in circles and throwing glitter in the air. Li Gong goes to visit him without Ze Shou and then later breaks up with Ze Shou. The impression given by that meeting is that Ze Shou's father was so against them being together that Li Gong felt the need to break up with Ze Shou so he can find happiness with a woman only to later find out that Ze Shou's father didn't really have a problem with their relationship and Li Gong basically acted on his own and everything got massively blown out of proportion. By the time both guys got their heads screwed on straight, I had pretty much lost interest and frankly didn't care much if they got together or not.

The second couple was kind of cute and I was invested in them at first, but I never felt like there was much depth to their relationship and I eventually just kind of tapped out. Their attraction to each other just seemed very surface level, and I needed more to really get why they fell in love with each other. I will say it was refreshing to see someone more ordinary looking like Ying Ze end up with someone like Yuki. It seems like most of the time in BL's most of the men are equally gorgeous. The discrepancy here gave some credence to the idea that their love isn't just based on physical appearance. I just wish more time had been devoted to their developing relationship as I think it could have been a really great addition. I also found the fight they had to be more realistic and less contrived. While Ying Ze's devotion to his job was a tad odd to the point he kept clothing that hadn't been picked up in 10+ years, based on his personality, I could get behind his anger at Yuki for getting rid of those clothes a little more. I think it was blown out of proportion and he stayed angry way longer than was necessary, but it worked better than the lead couple's break up.

The chemistry between all the couples was lacking for me. The more intimate scenes just fell flat for me. The actors were obviously committed, but I just didn't feel a spark.

I would have really liked if this drama had used its women better. I'm used to BL dramas using their female characters as props but this drama in particular did them dirty. The male leads go to great lengths to get rid of the women they've been set up on blind dates with and while I get its meant to be funny, I also can't help but feel bad for those women. But I feel like the real injustice is done to Xue Ching, Ze Shou's sister, and Nikita. Xue Ching essentially serves as her brother's punching bag. He doesn't really let her get a word in edgewise and constantly shuts her down. She seemed like she could have been a fun and interesting character so I was disappointed she didn't get a chance to shine. Nikita started out as the cool, unruffled bar manager. I really liked her and her insights and the way she just seemed to observe everyone. She kind of came across as that bartender who'll really listen to you and give you solid advice. And then they went and had her like Li Gong and just ruined her. Those scenes just seemed so completely out of character and also out of the blue. As with a lot of this drama, it felt very contrived.

The less said about the music the better, especially the opening song. It just did not do it for me.

There are a couple of positives in addition to the negatives. I really enjoyed seeing the characters in their work environments. It added an extra dimension to their characters and was genuinely interesting, particularly the law aspect. Ze Shou and Li Gong quoting law to each other was a fun addition towards the beginning of the drama and I wish they'd continued it throughout. Seeing them working as lawyers and working with their clients was a unique addition and one that I appreciated. The cinematography was overall pretty good, and there were a number of well done shots. Honestly though, the highlight of this drama for me was seeing Aaron Lai and Hank Wang from Be Loved in House: I Do. That is one of my absolute favorite dramas and I was so happy to see them again.

This drama could have been decent if it had stopped around Episode 8, things just started to go downhill afterward before completely imploding. It kind of redeems itself in the end, but not enough to warrant ever watching it again. Its short enough that you can pretty easily binge watch it which is what I did. The relatively short length is the only reason I stuck with it to the end. Its decent enough to warrant watching at least once, just be prepared for the train wreck that is Episodes 9-11.

Leggi di Più

Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Completo
Cooking Crush
0 persone hanno trovato utile questa recensione
feb 18, 2024
12 di 12 episodi visti
Completo 0
Generale 6.5
Storia 5.5
Acting/Cast 7.5
Musica 7.0
Valutazione del Rewatch 5.0
Questa recensione può contenere spoiler

Not Much Cooking

I watched this series solely for Off/Gun because they were so phenomenal in Not Me, but Not Me and Cooking Crush are polar opposites in every way. Cooking Crush is a rom-com but unfortunately neither the rom or the com was done particularly well and as a whole it lacked substance. It was generically cute with nothing to make it stand out from the legion of other Thai rom-coms. The cooking aspect, which could have made it more unique, was not utilized well enough to make a mark. With such a stellar cast, I'm disappointed that it didn't live up to it's potential.

Cooking Crush really leaned into the comedic side of things from the get go with heavy use of sound effects and exaggerated acting from its cast. But it wasn't well thought out, intelligent humor, it was simply cheesy and, in a number of cases, cringeworthy. In fact, it was so painful and not to my taste that I very nearly dropped it then and there. The main plot centers around Prem, a cooking student, who meets Ten, a med student, in a series of unfortunate events that eventually leads to Ten trying Prem's food and finding it to be absolutely delicious. He proceeds to ask Prem to teach him to cook which Prem refuses until he's in need of money to pay for his sister's school and agrees, though he charges an exorbitant price that Ten is all too willing to pay. From there they slowly fall in love, facing a few up and downs with time spent apart, the disapproval of Ten's father, and a brief scandal. The secondary couple of Dynamite, Prem's fellow cooking student friend, and Fire, a pharmacy student and Ten's friend, focuses on Fire separating himself from his domineering mother and finally having the freedom and opportunity to discover himself and come to terms with his own sexuality. Dynamite, having fallen for Fire some time previously, relentlessly pursues Fire, sometimes stalking him, in an effort to win him over which is eventually successful though they still have to contend with Fire's mother once she finds out. Secondary to the romance is Prem and his friends journey to be on a popular cooking show and the various challenges they face with it. It's a very simple series without much depth and it can stray into being downright tedious times. And for a show called Cooking Crush, I expected a much greater focus on the cooking and, once the cooking show began, on it. But while food is certainly woven throughout the story and is utilized well at times, there was a lack of detail that made it seem shallow. For all that Prem was supposed to be teaching Ten to cook, it felt more like a cooking demonstration as Ten wasn't seen doing a whole lot. The show, which could have been a great way to lean into the cooking aspect, was not well defined and key elements like the tasting and judges' comments on the food were left out. The pacing was slow. It could have very easily been condensed into ten, maybe even fewer episodes. There's a fair amount of filler with nothing going on or just sweet scenes between the couples which were not needed.

The characters themselves had both highs and lows to them, though Ten and Prem were certainly the highlight. One of the biggest downsides was that they were all supposed to be college students and yet the immaturity level made them seem more like high school students or even younger. There were also a few character inconsistencies, namely, Ten's father scolds him for using his fists to defend Prem, but a few episodes earlier he had slapped Ten himself. Despite that, there was some decent character development which I did appreciate.
-Prem is a budding chef who has the skills to succeed but lacks the confidence to do so. Prem's journey, besides romantic, is learning to develop his self-confidence and have faith in himself and his skills. Of course there's also his relationship with Ten, which starts out rocky, but quickly takes on a romantic note when the pair develop mutual feelings. Though there are moments of immaturity between the two, having their friends run messages between them being a big one, they are generally pretty solid together. Other than the aforementioned case and one or two other instances, communication is generally a strong point between them. Their support for each other is also quite endearing. I was, however, surprised when he started making unilateral decisions for his team after the drama with Ten punching Chang Ma. It felt out of character for him.
-Ten is a shy med student haunted by his past. He can be a bit of a hot head, but he learns from the mistakes he makes and more importantly is willing to admit to those mistakes and apologize for them. His love for Prem pushes him out of his comfort zone and helps solidify what he wants in life. His unending support and encouragement of Prem was very sweet. We should all have such support in our lives.
-Dynamite is characterized by his fiery personality that refuses to be contained or in any way diminished. He loves fiercely and gives his all, no matter the situation. Though his pursuit of Fire does stray into downright stalking, he's not creepy or threatening about it, just overenthusiastic, not that that makes it okay. He does eventually learn to respect Fire's boundaries and gains some maturity. Hiding their relationship from their friends though is not one of their smarter moves and does cause damage when Unky finds out he was left in the dark when Prem knew. It's a learning experience for all involved. And while he does grow and mature, he also never loses sight of who he is which I found admirable.
- Fire is the one character who experiences an identity crisis when faced with the fact that he might not be straight. Controlled and suppressed by his domineering mother, he is only allowed to explore his own wants and desires after she allows him to move out. And while he is clearly drawn to Dynamite, he is reluctant to voice the possibility that he may be into guys. One thing that I appreciated throughout this drama is that there are no labels. No one is identified as strictly gay or straight and none of the challenges they face in their relationships are related to their sexuality. It's refreshing. Once Fire recognizes his own feelings and accepts them, he's all in, quickly turning into a sweet, loving boyfriend. Perhaps a little too abrupt of a change for my taste. And while he may not see eye to eye with his mother, I did like the way their relationship was portrayed and how once he gained the courage to actually tell her how he felt, she respected that and was open to talking.
-Unky stood out to me with his passion and determination. The oldest of his friends, he faces the fear that they'll eventually decide to leave him behind, a fear that is the driving force behind his fight with in Ep 9. The way that they assuage those fears is very wholesome and creates a sweet scene. I do wish we'd seen a bit more maturity from him given that he was older than the others, but I suppose that's a fairly minor complaint. His budding relationship in the last episode with Pang was cute though I wish it had been introduced earlier.
-Chang Ma was an unnecessary character, at least as a love interest. I would have much preferred for him to be left as a mentor and friend for Prem rather than someone who came in and tried to stir up trouble. I actually quite liked him at first, but when he started pushing boundaries and vying for Prem's affection even though it was obvious he had feelings for Ten, official or not, he lost my respect. He did eventually get the message and helped to take the heat off of Prem's team after Ten punched him, but the damage was done as far as I was concerned.
-With the parents, I liked the fact that the gender of their child's partner was never an issue, even with Ten's father. He was concerned about Prem trying to scam Ten, not that Prem was also a man. And I loved Prem's grandmother and how supportive she was of Prem in everything. She was an absolute gem.

The acting was not quite as strong as I was expecting. I know how strong of actors Off and Gun are and this was not their best work. While the chemistry was there, it just wasn't at the same level as it was in Not Me or even Theory of Love. Neo was good as always, though having just seen him in Only Friends, his performance wasn't quite as strong here. Newbie Aungpao was entertaining as Dynamite and while it was obvious he wasn't quite as seasoned as the other actors, he still did a good job and was fun to watch. Dome was one of the stronger actors and I thought he did a great job giving a nuance performance.

The production value was decent. The uncut version has a much better flow whereas the cut version had some choppy scenes and cuts. I would definitely recommend the uncut version as it provides more insight into various characters and their actions/interactions. However, even in the uncut, there are still some awkward jumps and tonal shifts. With the cooking element, no offense to the actors, but not once did I believe they were actually culinary students. Their knife and cooking skills/technique was not up to snuff. This is where clever camera angles, close ups of hands and the like, etc. could have been utilized to fool viewers into thinking they were far more skilled than they appeared.

Ultimately I found Cooking Crush to be disappointing. Given the caliber of its cast, it could have been so much more, but the overly campy nature of it really suppressed their talent and it didn't have the weight it could have had. I would have loved to have seen a more serious take, with some humor still thrown in, and more of a focus on the food and how it brings the characters together. But that's just me, I prefer dramas like Not Me over ones like Cooking Crush. If you're an Off/Gun fan, you may very well enjoy it or if camp is your genre of choice, but if you are looking for something more akin to Not Me, this is not the drama for you.

Leggi di Più

Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Completo
Miracle
0 persone hanno trovato utile questa recensione
nov 18, 2023
13 di 13 episodi visti
Completo 2
Generale 8.5
Storia 7.0
Acting/Cast 8.5
Musica 9.0
Valutazione del Rewatch 8.5
Questa recensione può contenere spoiler

Near and Dear

Kiseki: Dear to Me is a lovely little drama that I found thoroughly enjoyable. While not without its faults, it largely makes up for them with an eclectic group of characters, a decently told story, good music, and some excellent acting. It does get a little bit busy and would have benefitted from a more streamlined and cohesive plot, but it's not to the point of being unwatchable. It thoroughly drew me in and I have zero regrets after watching it.

In it's simplest form, this is an enemies to lovers story but the premise is unique enough that it doesn't feel totally cliche. Bai Zong Yi is a studious, rather grumpy student whose life is upended when the charismatic and mischievous gangster Fan Ze Rui blackmails him into taking him in and treating his wounds. There's no sense that one has more power than the other and that contributes to the interest and entertainment as the two learn to live together and eventually fall in love. I appreciated that the time frame was made clear. There's no question of whether a scene is past, present, or future. It begins in the present with a short little scene and then jumps to four years previously in 2019 and carries on from there. However, there's a lot going on and while the developing romance between Zong Yi and Ze Rui takes the front, there's also the ongoing fighting with a rival gang and trying to sniff out drug dealers at the local school. It's a lot to pack in and the story suffers for it. A decent amount could have been condensed or cut completely to allow more time for character development, providing more detailed information and world building, or giving more time to the episodes set in the present. For example, it would have been nice to have a more clear understanding of the gangs and how they worked. Things jump forward four years after Episode 8 and while I don't generally like time jumps, I understand the necessity of this one. Now set in the present day, the story becomes more, not less convoluted. There's not much time to get everything wrapped up and some things are left hanging. The memory aspect was a big one for me. Both Zong Yi and Ze Rui suffer brain injuries, but with Ze Rui it's unclear if he truly lost his memory for a period of time or if he was just faking it the entire time. With Zong Yi, he suffered short term memory impairment which was not explored or well explained. He uses a notebook to jot down important events, but it doesn't seem to effect his life too much and is largely forgettable. There are also some irritating moments where dramatic or misleading things happen but turn out to be nothing. Two primary examples would be when Chen Yi got shot and that served as a cliffhanger but was ultimately nothing and the last episode where an attempt is made to trick the audience into thinking Ze Rui has died. Both instances were cheap and unnecessary. The pacing was all over the place, but generally felt rushed. Again, just trying to fit in way too much. Particularly towards the end, there were a lot of moving parts and scenes that should have held significance weren't given the time they deserved. There needed to be a better balance between episodes focused on the past and then the present and that just wasn't there.

I am generally not a fan of romances between adults and minors. There's too much room for the adult to take advantage of the minor and manipulate them. However, I was less bothered here because there was an element that it was necessary to the story. Also Zong Yi was seventeen and while he did have some young, impulsive moments, his feelings for Ze Rui did not feel impulsive and their love did feel genuine. And Ze Rui did have clear moments of conflict and he did try to create distance. All of that combined evened things out for me. I know the teacher/student aspect bothered a number of people, but personally, due to the nature of the circumstances surrounding it, I didn't have an issue with it.

The character development was pretty decent and was certainly present. Not as much with the main leads as I would have thought though, at least not positively. I did find the second couple of Ai Di and Chen Yi to be more interesting and satisfying to watch. The largest issue with the characters was an overabundance of them. There were too many side characters and relatively insignificant characters to try to keep track of.
-Zong Yi starts out grouchy and closed off, but once he falls in love with Ze Rui, it's like he has a personality transplant and is suddenly largely kind and gentle. While he has a few grumpy moments, they seem largely for show. I would have preferred a more gradual change to his character and I would have liked to see him retain some of his original characteristics rather than becoming a whole new person. He's also a little too perfect. Aside from the last episode when he's pissed that Ze Rui didn't think of him when he was stabbed, he doesn't express any anger or resentment towards him for what happened in the past. That felt unrealistic. He should have felt something other than regret that he couldn't protect them both.
-Ze Rui remained largely the same throughout. While he expresses guilt and regret for what happened in the past with Zong Yi, he doesn't appear to really change. He's still a manipulative person but he has a good heart. Frankly, I thought he got off way too easy. Zong Yi suffered a lot because of him, from serving jail time to having permanent brain damage that dashed his dreams of becoming a doctor. Ze Rui didn't apparently suffer any permanent damage from his head injury and aside from being stabbed by Zhang Teng's sister which doesn't seem to actually be that serious, there are no consequences.
- Ai Di in particular was a delight and hands down my favorite character. He was small but mighty and I loved his attitude. He was fiercely loyal to his friends and to Chen Yi, who he'd been in love with for years. Forced to play second fiddle, he nonetheless stays by Chen Yi's side to help him even sacrificing himself to protect him and do what's necessary after Zong Yi is injured in prison. What's so great about him is that he does grow and develop, yet he remains true to himself. There's never any doubt that he is Ai Di.
-Chen Yi starts out in love with one of the gang's bosses and only becomes aware of Ai Di's feelings when he and Ai Di sleep together after he's been drinking. He also discovers the birthday presents Ai Di had gotten for him over the years and eventually comes to realize both Ai Di's and his own feelings. His attempts in the present to win over Ai Di are both humorous and adorable. Once they get together, it's like nothing's changed and yet everything has changed. Their dynamic is the same, but they're obviously in love. They balance each other out very nicely.
-The other characters were largely unimpressive. Although I did love Zong Yi's father and sister and how loving and supportive they were. Their interactions were so wholesome. The boss and his man were an interesting addition. We don't generally see older BL couples, so I appreciated that they were included from that perspective, however, they were not well utilized and they had so little screen time that they felt superfluous. Zhang Teng was a pretty boring villain. I didn't really find the lollipop to be off-putting, I just found him to be over the top and non-threatening. There needed to be more to him to make him feel like a viable threat. Even his history with Ze Rui felt incomplete and rushed. Suh Ning as his sister out for revenge was not a well developed plot point. It was obvious she was up to something, but there needed to be a greater buildup.

The acting was well done, but the undisputed star of the show was Louis as Ai Di. He was so committed to the role and he was a stand out in every way. He had great chemistry with Nat whose acting was more understated, but still good. Hsu and Taro were both pretty strong, though it was obvious at times that this was Taro's first role and he's still young and green. They both did a fair amount of acting with just their eyes and I was impressed with their chemistry, especially considering their 10 year age gap. I did enjoy the cameo of the actors from Be Loved In House. I keep hoping they'll get another series. And it was nice to see An Jun of HIStory 4 again. He had more than a cameo role and he did a good job. There was also a cameo from two of the actors of Plus & Minus, though I wasn't a fan of that drama so I had to go look them up to figure out why they looked familiar.

The production quality was a mixed bag for me. There were some really great transitions and cuts and then there were some pretty subpar ones. The lighting was sometimes too bring and other times bordering on too dark. There was just a general lack of consistency. I did like the costuming, particularly for Ai Di. The man was a style icon. I loved his unique look and how well it fit his character. The music was also good and worked well where used.

It's not perfect, but it's fun. It's not a drama you can look at too closely because once you do, things start to unravel. But if you just go with it, it's a great ride. This is definitely one I would recommend and one I will be rewatching in the future.

Leggi di Più

Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Completo
Our Skyy 2: Star in My Mind
0 persone hanno trovato utile questa recensione
apr 29, 2023
2 di 2 episodi visti
Completo 0
Generale 7.0
Storia 6.5
Acting/Cast 7.5
Musica 7.5
Valutazione del Rewatch 6.0
Questa recensione può contenere spoiler

A Surprising Star

Between Star in My Mind and Sky in Your Heart, I much preferred Sky in Your Heart. Star in My Mind had some decent moments, but I wasn't overly fond of Daonuea or Khabkluen or their story. It leaned more towards the typical college romance showcased in BLs and I preferred the maturity of Sky in Your Heart. So going into watching these two episodes, I didn't have high expectations. I figured I would watch it for the sake of saying that I'd seen it and be done with it. Imagine my surprise when I found that I actually overall enjoyed these episodes and found them equal parts funny and endearing.

These two episodes are essentially just fluff without a whole lot of substance. Nothing dramatic happens, it's basically just Khabkluen and Daonuea being in love and telling each other how much they love the other. It's sweet. I liked that what was showcased was a healthy relationship. They communicate with each other. Daonuea has no qualms about bringing up the jealousy matter and Khabkluen clearly appreciates it and is happy to reiterate that there is no one else for him besides Daonuea. They are clearly very secure in their relationship and it's really nice to see that. There's also the element of consent. Khabkluen is the more vocal and demonstrative of the pair in showing his love for Daonuea. Despite the length of time they've been together, he's still very conscious of how Daonuea feels and frequently makes sure that he is okay with what is happening between them when things get romantic. It was just another aspect that was refreshing.

Their friends were entertaining. I don't always love the sidekicks in dramas, they can trend more towards annoying than funny in some cases, but I really enjoyed these guys. They were entertaining to watch with their antics and the way they teased their two friends. I also liked the way Typhoon was handled. They could have made him sad or bitter, unable to move on from Daonuea, but instead they not only showed him moving on but even revealed that he was able to be friends with Daonuea. I really appreciated that growth in his character, that he was able to be happy for Daonuea and support his relationship with Khabkluen.

The acting was okay. I don't think either Dunk or Joong are amazing actors, but I will acknowledge that they're young and have time to continue to grow and improve. I think Joong is the stronger actor of the pair and I did prefer his performance to Dunk's. That being said, they both have improved since Star in My Mind. Their chemistry together isn't bad, but leans more towards buddy than romance at times. Still, it's clear that they have a good rapport with each other which does translate to the screen, even if it's not exactly what they were going for perhaps. Pawin, Pepper, Winny and Satang again were entertaining as the friends. All four performed their parts well. I only wish we could have had Mek and Mark back again as Fah and Prince, but I knew with Mek having left GMMTV that wasn't going to happen.

These two episodes completely exceeded my expectations which, to be fair, wasn't hard since they were pretty low. Still, they made me laugh and smile and delivered some good moments. I think they demonstrated how to write a romance without the need of a lot of skinship to distract from the substandard plot or characters. Yes, there are kisses and such, but it's not sexy, it really is just romantic; a happy and healthy couple who clearly love each other and don't need to go around ripping each other's clothes off. It was a refreshing change. I would recommend these episodes as they truly tell just a feelgood story.

Leggi di Più

Questa recensione ti è stata utile?