8 for potential...dissapointed by production. 6.5-7 would be a real rating
Just finished it and will go see part 2.I gave it an 8 for the potential, but a more accurate rating would be a 7/10. The plot has potential and I hope season 2 will do better than this but I have many doubts...
What makes is not so great in my opinion(every complain is about the production):
• short and rushed: they tried to squeeze as much as they could as far as feelings and plot setting goes and because of that they failed to do something awesome
- this covers that awkward feeling I got from the characters too since they couldn't be developed/presented properly and some of their interactions are also "awkward-cringey" not in a good way
- some "buffer scenes" that usually prepare the viewer to get into the right mood/feeling are missing so it feels like one of those episode short stories where they transition in the middle of it and it makes you lose focus about what is currently happening/lets you thinking about what happened in the last scene/waiting for something more even thought there may be nothing(long story short: bad transitions)
• bad scene cuts that simply feel like a slap in the middle of something that feels interesting(even in some fight scenes, but there it might be because of the cgi/budget/ not enough filmed scenes or well thought before shooting)
• half of the fight scenes are mediocre because they tried too much to emphasize the supernatural movements and are simply "meh" (illogical, felt awkward in some places, bad scene cut/transitions/positions after a "high speed action")
• plot holes: yeah, I know it's a drama and also fantasy, but there are scenes(too many considering how short it is) in which the action taken by a character makes you wanna scream "really?" (best example would be last episode when the priest turns away and prays....REALLY???? IN THAT SITUATION??? Which screenwriter and/or producer is this dumb to make that scene so cringe and illogical? There was no reason, no emotion, no logic, not anything that would make that action have a meaning. Please watch the scene before commenting about my comment about it.).
There are multiple scenes like this and it simply screams at how this whole project feels like a homework that was well thought
and planned, forgotten and made half an hour before the class starts.
I won't say any specific details because it would be a spoiler. I want this to be read by everyone and to know what they are getting from this kdrama and that is a failed potential top rated kdrama.
Acting - felt ok, but again, because of the rushed storytelling they didn't have a chance to trully shine
Soundtrack - decent, but nothing great. Would have loved an epic theme song to be done for this like moorim school had or ar least a better work done in some scene where a better soundtrack would've made them feel even better
It is decent overall, but mediocre and I'm sad because it had a great potential.
Worth watching if you wanna see something fast and without getting attached to the characters/story.
Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Its not my kind of drama
Everyone got differents taste when it comes to dramas, and this one its not my type ig. I guess thats why i didnt understand the story and got lost as the drama was developing or maybe in the 2nd season they'll answer all the cuestions I got because what was that???? 6 episodes and they didn't clear nothing... i guess the story is going nowhere.I think the cast was so good and they gave an excellent performance, especially Cha Eunwoo which acting has gotten so much better. Maybe one day I'll give a chance to the 2nd season but for now Im not in the mood of watching more dark dramas, or maybe this drama was excessively dark.
Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Oh...word? OH, WORD?!
The headline was my inner monologue throughout this drama because damn, there's a lot to unpack. 😅 Supernatural dramas are my fav, and supernatural dramas featuring a love interest between a human and non-human are my kryptonite-- so this one definitely piqued my interest. For starters, I really enjoyed the story and feel like if you enjoyed Tale of the Nine-Tailed or Goblin, you will probably enjoy this. It has similar aspects to the love story in Nine-Tailed and a similar destiny story to Goblin, which were my favorite parts of both of those series. Island is much less light, though...we are deeeeeep in the angst/sorrow/revenge/ass kicking/saving the world.So the story by itself: 10/10...but the storyTELLING/editing was really really jarring and awkward in multiple places, which is why I gave the story category an 8/10. On multiple occasions we would end a super intense fight scene and, without any segue, go into another super intense fight scene that we had little to no introduction of. We'd go through a scene, feel the emotions, and then not have any time to process those emotions, before going straight into a scene that registered on a high emotional level, but meanwhile I'm still trying to process 3 previous scenes...ya feel? It's difficult to explain, and it happened more (or was more noticeable) in the second part, but it happened enough times for me to take notice, and for it to affect the story flow.
With that said, I still really enjoyed this part and would recommend any supernatural drama lover to give it a chance. It is action packed, angsty, intense, super cool monsters and fight scenes, and the actors were very likeable. 👍
Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Lần đầu tiên xem thể loại fantasy-thriller mà tôi khóc
Tôi thường xem các phim rom-com hơn là những phim thriller vì không phải gì, nhưng tôi xem phim này vì Kim Nam Gil và bị cuốn theo phim lúc nào không biết. Tôi dần dần bị cuốn vào sợi dây tình cảm của Van MiHo, một bộ đôi có chemistry tưởng không hợp mà lại hợp không tưởng trên mà ảnh, biên kịch và đạo diễn đã cho những sự dễ thương ngọt ngào vào phim mặc dù đây không phải là rom-com nhưng lại vô cùng hợp. Có điều phim hơi ngắn, quá nhiều cảnh hành động nên nhiều khi xem phim cũng bị dội vì không phải gu. Nhưng tổng kết là phim khá hay, mọi người ạ. Hãy xem nha, phim ai cũng đẹp hết á, Kim Nam Gil diễn xuất sắc với ngầu vãi lun!Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
ineedvagabondseason2asap
0 persone hanno trovato utile questa recensione
Scarttered plot
Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Questa recensione può contenere spoiler
Even Cha Eun Woo Couldn't Save This
Normally I keep little notes to myself as I watch a drama and then I use those notes to write a detailed review but I honestly I can't be bothered. I was not motivated to write the review immediately after finishing it and since I just finished Vincenzo I think it's time I put in some review. So I'm just going to leave my notes to myself because that's about all it's worth.Okay, only on episode two but can no one else see this insane shit going on? I just saw the car chase part and the little kid in the back seat who could clearly see it, but the mom driving doesn't? Like wtf.
FL is an insufferable brat. Also, she does the most irresponsible shit for someone being hunted by demons. Goes to sleep with balcony wide open, exercising outdoors at night. It's like she wants to die.
Her calling Van a coward for not trying to save the girl is insane when she totally blew her off.
Some of her outfits are amazing. Like the blue dress when her and butler and trying to figure out how to take revenge on behalf of that young girl. That was giving me IU Hotel Del Luna vibes. But some of other things, like the weirdly large, weirdly shaped light blue shorts. The weird pink fuzzy sweater with again, weirdly shaped shorts and knee high boots (for her, somehow, SECOND day as a teacher). lol
I'm sorry, "Where have you been... uncle?" UNCLE? WHAT!?
Okay, much time has passed and now Granny is there to save that little two-timing brat. She knows right from wrong and gave her best friend hell for her choices while she was doing this shit?
Also, granny telling dude that his hatred is all for nothing is wild. I hate him, but he absolutely has every right to be hateful. They were forced into being a demon slayers, kept captive, and then they tried to burn them alive.
Also, given how they were all about the greater good, why tf would granny give up all her children for this two-timing brat of all people?
JOHAN DIES!? OMG thank god. I almost had a heart attack. And what a comeback!
This ending already has me irate.
Also, I appreciate shirtless Cha Eun Woo and I like them showing the back scar but they forgot to put his kidney scar on lol
Worst ending ever. Zero happiness. Proves again that they should've killed that annoying little back-stabbing bitch when they had the chance.
Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Good Enough
Korean Drama " Island " is the first part of the sci fi fantasy drama that is a webtoon adaption.The drama has some intriguing characters and a gothic mood to it, with a few notions of horror and a lot of mystical plotlines.
It would have aided the drama a lot with the two main characters had more scenes together and better chemistry to justify their 'bond' and help the viewer engage and care about them.
The story, also, needed more time to have a proper development.
Nevertheless, it was enjoyable and the performances were pretty nice.
So, overall, seven out of ten.
Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Grandes escenarios en un contenido vacío.
En pocas palabras: una serie mala, no creo que entra en el término mediocre porque hay más elementos negativos que positivos. Las interpretaciones son correctas aunque me hubiera gustado que el personaje de Van, fuera un poco más humano, y no pareciera un robot sin sentimientos. La igual lo que haga siempre tiene la misma expresión de aburrimiento. Su enemigo, que se supone que no tiene sentimientos humanos, tiene mucho más desarrrollo emocional que Van, y eso dice mucho. No me gustó el personaje de Won Mi Ho, o es la típica miñata rica que piensa que puede hacer lo que quiera que para eso tiene millones o es la sacerdotista con el espíritu de un flan. El padre JOhan es un joven exorcista que pero que al final parece ser otra cosa. Debe ser como Popeye que cuando comía espinacas le daban super fuerza, en su caso será la fé cristiana. O el pendiente. No lo tengo claro. No sé, otro personaje que tiene un desarrollo nada coherente.La historia es mala. Hay muchas cosas que no tiene sentido. Hay diálogos que dan hasta un poco de vergüenza.
Lo único que podría salvar es al Padre Johan, que al menos alegra la vista. Y no puedo olvidar la fotografía, La serie tiene unos escenarios maravillosos, te dan ganas de visitar la isla.
Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Disappointment!
So, this drama is probably the worst one I have ever seen. The screenwriting, production, storyline, and effects are so bad that it is hard to believe that it is a Korean drama. I did not really care about the characters, and the only positive thing I found was the flashback from their past. The first episode was so hard for me to watch, but I gave it a chance. However, I had to drop it at episode 4 as I could not waste my time any longer.To be honest, I do not understand how the rating can be so high.
Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Island
I have watched because of the genre and Cha Eun Woo - and he did great, his character was fun and really like his blue eyes. Well this season/part/however you call it had more interesting plot or better made eventhough I like second season more. It is not a bad drama but splitting it into to parts was unneccessary.Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Fun Urban Fantasy
It's been so long since I wanted to binge a kdrama, Island might be tropey or not particularly memorable in the long run, but it sure is having fun wielding its demon slashing blade along the way.Great chemistry among the cast is a gamechanger for me, yes, it's a waste for Kim Nam Gil to play a badass stoic demon hunter, as he can express his way through anything , but I'm such a sucker for these types of grumpy/sunshine loveline. He's so good at "longing yet irritated" gazes directed to Lee Da Hee.
Cha Eun Woo looks like he's having a blast playing that cool exorcist priest. There might be quite a few Mi Ho being chased around by demons, until Van saves her, but here's hoping it grows into her developing her powers and they can all kickass together. I love this trio, and can anyone blame me? I'm kind of sick of all the doom and gloom in other shows.
Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Questa recensione può contenere spoiler
muito bom
amei nsudbksbdjebdus susbnmmmdbdj djs zuar sus dje sua seu du edu edfjdx djx xjd xi djx jjkkkkksls.zkz x xj. di did ei deu dux dud duas sua js u sh sjssjx x xjc dj cjc di xj. dj eis ci rico di. dj. sjduenxu du eux eu edu eud eu eue ue eu eud eu edh du. fica ru rj rj rjd jejd dhr jdrhe ie did djd djd djd jd djd djd djd di dj d dxjd xj xjx xjx xj. i j j j jj j j j j jj j u t t tg h u k i u f d d g. f s r g v d e. f c hy. d c. e s. s d dnud. j. u dj. cns hx d xj. dj du nunca h br kuvt j vt j bg sbx i. ei eix ei did. i did. i eic eif djd j. ejd. fj. ejd simfuw r mais ermic wkeur wi. wu rnfoauve fiz wye fins auh e ifc. sim vi.s u wjxQuesta recensione ti è stata utile?