Ok so he is dead in the end. Weird twist;
the movie would have been just fine had he been alive and went back to see her. Keeping one promise is paramount!

Fine I get it. You wanted to throw a curve ball ? in there so you decided you wanted to negatively interrupt the viewer emotions with a crazy ending.

Atleast show or say how he died.
I didnt invest 2hours of my life just to be left bewildered.
Crazy!! am not happy at all, I wish I didn't watch it moving forward I will be checking Asian movies and dramas for happy ending, before watching.

I don't know what's the crazy obsession to have unhappy ending.

For crying out loud! Put the dramatic emotional roller coastsr in the middle and give us the happy ending.

trust me if the heartache is in the middle, we will still feel the pain, especially if it was well written and portrayed well by the actors.

Going back to movie removing my rating from a 8 to a 7.
got me thinking i missed something, like how did he died!!!!!