In all honesty this review will probably be ignored or swept aside for more recent reviews by drama fans. Nonetheless, I will say that I actually watched this drama several years back after having read several chapters of the eponymous webtoon .

Not remembering much about the drama ( apart from some lacklustre chemistry and plot) I decided to have another attempt at watching Orange Marmalade . It was only when watching it for a second time . did I realise that Orange Marmalade truly was its own worst enemy when it came to story progression and episode pacing throughout the show.

Of course that’s not to say that the show was entirely dire ; the premise itself of an alternative reality where vampires are outcasts amongst human society ( similar to the webtoon ) was intriguing, the casting choices of fairly top-notch actors such as Seolhyun and Yeo Jin Goo as our leads added to the appeal and even having Lee Hyung Min ( Strong Woman Do Bong Soon and I’m Sorry, I Love You) and Choi Sung bum ( Jungle Fish and My ID is Gangnam Beauty) as the directors nearly sealed the drama’s fate to be a masterpiece.

So just what went wrong with such a potentially brilliant show? Well, the biggest factor was most certainly to do with the episode pacing.

Although we are introduced to our main female protagonist Baek Ma Ri ( Seolhyun) as well as the majority of our main characters in the first few episodes, there’s simply no scenes dedicated for viewers to actually get to know
our protagonists as individuals, such as ; (despite her circumstances as a “ vampire”,) Ma Ri is not shown to be as subjected or act in strong emotion ( apart from supposed “ fear”) against her peers finding out, ( unlike the webtoon) there’s little explanation or motivation shown behind Jung Jae Min’s ( Yeo Jin Goo) enmity towards vampires , and there is also very little reasoning behind Han Shi Hoo’s caution around humans. In addition to these problems, there’s also the added flaw of the show having what’s called a “ loose plot “ motive ( “ the vampire girl hides her identity”) without a greater sense of purpose ( i.e. a greater threat, antagonist or challenge) for our characters or the general progression of the storyline.

When we did actually get to see some character bond development between Jae Min and Ma Ri, a sudden time-skip for several episodes without reason or purpose to the Joseon period, destroyed this relationship’s genuine development in a matter of seconds.

It isn’t necessarily that these flashbacks shouldn’t have been included in the plot, however, it would have made more sense to have either shown us this in the beginning of the series ( as perhaps two episodes maximum) in order to build-up to the characters’ introductions in the present day, having interwoven flashbacks over the course of the drama ( either through parallel actions of our characters to the past or even through dreams) or just simply using the earlier episodes to characterise our protagonists more as individuals before introducing this new storyline into the mix .

Overall Orange Marmalade’s sweetened visage as a romance drama with an intriguing premise, is a facade for the acrid citric bitterness of terrible story writing ,plot pacing and characterisation. Certainly not worth committing time towards.