A história do "palco" é uma cópia barata e mal feita de BOF/Hana Yori Dango, é bem bobinha, brega, clichê e sem graça. Não tiveram a dignidade de pelo menos mostrar uma amizade forte como os F4, a relação de "amizade" dos A3 é bem superficial. Se a intenção era fazer uma sátira aos clichês de BOF/HYD não colou, não teve graça.
Quanto aos personagens:
- A protagonista é maravilhosa, não tenho dúvidas, sua interpretação foi muito boa e sua personagem é realmente muito fácil de gostar.
- O Haru parece um robô é bem irritante de assistir como ele se movimenta.
- Amei o Do Hwa, coitadinho (injustiçado).
No final você tem a estranha sensação de ter visto muito sem ter visto nada! Talvez este drama funcione melhor para uma faixa etária de até 17-18 anos. Sinceramente, se você já assistiu a dramas escolares como: When We Where Young, My Youth, Atention, Love!, Sassy, Go Go não perca seu tempo com este drama.
Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Questa recensione può contenere spoiler
My most favorite drama ever!
This is my 50th time watching it always tops my list Whenever i feel low, i watch this drama and i easily forget abt the surroundings and started to laugh with them cry etc moments. Nowadays i feel none of them making nyc rom-com series like this one, true beauty, CLOY,DOTS ,Snowdrop, My love from another star,WWWSK ,etc many more. Idk when we will get nice romantic kdrama again so i am rewatching all the classic series once again. Recent times only twinkling watermelon ? is epic and proper classic drama too.Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Questa recensione può contenere spoiler
Au début je m'attendais à pas grand chose mais je voulais me regarder un drama assez light, type rom—com. Alors au début ça part très bien: des personnages intéressants, une histoire originale, une prise de vue assez intéressante du type narrateur personnage (Eun Dan Oh).Et puis soudain ça retombe: pleins de choses tombent à la trap, le monde créé s'essouffle.
Partie spoiler :
Les ambitions de Eun Dan Oh hop évaporé pour ne vivre qu'à travers une romance.
Haru un personnage qui n'évolue pas et qui ne prend pas plus de profondeur.
Des actions/discussions intéressantes dans les premiers épisodes qui ne sont pas utilisés ensuite.
À pleins d'écart j'aurais aimé des relations plus poussées que les romances.
Ect
Heureusement que l'acteur jouant Baek Kyung était là pour tenir un peu la barque malgré un personnage pas simple à tenir. C'est le seul qui m'a un peu ému.
Du côté de certaines intrigues secondaires ça allait aussi.
Dans l'ensemble un drama en dent de scie, je n'ai pas lu le mawha mais je pense que le principal soucis de cohérence du monde vient de là donc ça aurait mérité d'avoir de meilleures bases malgré une idée originale car même si ça pourrait être associé à W par le thème, le traitement est totalement différent.
Côté OST c'est assez basique rien qui n'a vraiment attiré mon oreille mais rien non plus de trop ennuyant à entendre.
Clairement peu de chances que je le revois. Et si c'est le cas je m'arrêter au ⅞ ème episode.
Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Tugs at the heart
This starts off as a send up of Boys Over Flowers. There's the poor scholarship girl at a prestigious private school who is bullied. F4 is now A3. There's even a guy who sheds a tear while playing his violin in public spaces.But then the students at Seuli High School start to figure out that they are characters in a graphic novel. A writer controls what they say or do. Most of them are horrified when they learn they aren't even one of the main characters. That's when this parody of K-drama rom-coms turns into a bittersweet reflection on fate, memory, and autonomy.
Extraordinary You made me giggle, and it made me cry, which doesn't happen too often.
Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Questa recensione può contenere spoiler
Embracing Responsibility: How Haru and Dan-oh Teach Us to Shape Our Own Destiny.
However, the 'trumpet creeper' mentioned in their previous literary work is utterly nonsensical if it were to be transformed into an actual comic ( out of this series ). I mean, why would the author choose to eliminate the main character? It defies all logic. I wholeheartedly agree with Dan-oh's assessment that this writer is abysmal, and it's highly unlikely that anyone would appreciate their book in the real world. How amusing! I must admit, though my own words may lack coherence, they too fail to make any sense.Ah, but this series is simply exquisite. I have indulged in its brilliance time and time again, and each viewing leaves me in tears when Haru vanishes. The pain of Dan-oh resonates within me, causing tears to flow incessantly. Yet, I find myself laughing and smiling like a fool whenever Haru and Dan-oh share a moment. It's as if all else fades away, and I am fully present, basking in the sheer joy of that very instant.
I have pondered this extensively and reached a profound conclusion: the writer is akin to a GOD, the characters represent us, and the scenes embody fate. Only when we become aware of our own existence (awakening to our oneness) can we triumph over the harsh realities of the world and live happily ever after, just like Haru and Dan-oh. Fate is merely an illusion, ingrained in us from a tender age. "Do not fret, remain resilient, and venture into the darkness, for God shall safeguard you." But why? No one will come to your rescue; you alone bear the responsibility for your own well-being, and you alone are accountable for everything that befalls you. Dan-oh and Haru assumed responsibility for their own lives and transformed their entire world. It is truly a beautiful notion. I adore it.
By relinquishing the notion of a protective God or an external ruling force, we can truly embrace the responsibility for our own actions and cease attributing everything to the whims of fate. We are the architects of our own reality, crafting our own world. However, I am uncertain if any of you will grasp the essence of my words. If you do, I wish you the best of luck and send you an abundance of love, accompanied by a warm embrace.
Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Questa recensione può contenere spoiler
as of the 25th episode…
i really enjoy this drama i love the twists and turns the story has taken up to this point and i am really invested in the plot. the music is really amazing i really enjoy the osts for this drama and another thing i like is that there is instrumental music as well. i feel like the casting was cone really well and i really really really enjoy the plot. I feel like i have never watched a show like this before with this kind of storyline.however there is one thing that i came to say and that is that I really dislike beak kyungs character.
SPOILERS BELOW
he really pisses me off when he says things like “ you’re just an extra” or “im the protagonists” “you cant escape your setup” and “you were made to be with me that is something you cannot change” then turns around and says that eun dan oh is using her setup as an excuse and whatever the hell he says. his character is so infuriating and he only exists to hurt everyone else and gets mad. he only wants to have eun dan oh because she was originally his and was being taken away from him. so controlling. it feels like he is the only one that agrees with the current storyline and setup that eun dan oh and him belong together and the only person that is acting according to the way he feels in this entire story is him so it feels like hes the writer. tho that is probably wrong.
however, i cant wait to see how this plays out though and haru is a cutie
Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Who Thought A "Main Character Syndrome" Drama Is A Good Idea?
The female lead is probably one of the most insufferable characters you might encounter in a drama. Despicable and repulsive through and through. Props to the actress for putting in the effort to sell it as such. The drama was destined to fail with how they adapted it. It suffered from the same problems most long-running webtoons suffer from, by over bloating the material with events, abandoning plotlines and threads along the way and lacking coherent structure as it progresses. Unfortunately, they forgot to accommodate to what a live action format might mandate. The leads, Joo Da and her love interest, were an example, they were used to kick start the series of events just to be worth less than a background white noise later on, despite their core involvement in the concept early on. The concept had a lot of potentials but the end product barely serviced a story, let alone, something watchable.Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
nothing is interesting
I watched it because I felt interesting even my friend suggested me to watch but i no nothing was there to watch in this drama........I wasted my entire day my precious time on watching this drama, even it is not interesting.......
also comparing this drama with W the two world.....
extraordinary you is nothing, also it was too childish and over cuteness of that actress was annoying....... also some characters were irritating and arrogant.....
instead of watching this i would have studied for my exams....
Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
An extraordinary series
I'm going to keep it short.This series has a very interesting plotline and interesting world which is what got me hooked in the first place. I think they execute it very well although some plotpoints could be explained better - but it did not bother me.
The cast is so great, i loved seeing every interaction between the side characters but also between the main characters. there wasn't a single moment where i was bored or indifferent towards what the characters were feeling. I felt very deeply for these characters and wanted so badly for them to have the happy end they wanted and deserved.
Go watch this!!! It's a classic and a staple K-drama for a good reason!!!
Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Simply Extraodinary!
Extraordinary you will always be in my top 5 Kdramas! It was so refreshing and everything about it was captivating from start to end. Most of the actors didnt have much experience at the time this drama was filmed, so it was impressive how good their performances were.The plot is just so interesting. It has a common story of "fighting to change your fate" but it's done perfectly. It's very funny, interesting, dramatic and adds so much magic and flavor to the typical high school romance story. Though I believe that destiny can't be changed, this drama was still very inspiring and uplifting, The fact that it revolved around characters being in a comic was already very interesting but they also added even more side plots like the female leads unhappy engagement, her forced personality in the comic book, her new love interest. It was all just so entertaining and never got boring. All the characters have such distinct personalities and the music and OST's are amazing!
This drama has so much to offer and i'd definitely sat it's a must watch for anyone who enjoys K-dramas. It's fresh, entertaining and easy to rewatch. 9.5/10!!
Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
I loved this Kdrama
This kdrama is pure gold. Haru is such a green flag and I love that. No toxic ml!! I also liked female lead. She wasn't this shy and "I can't defend myself" girl. Felt sorry for the second lead (The friend of female lead, not the guy she was paired with)I laughed and cried a lot watching this Drama. It was confusing at times, and the ending has also left me confused. I had hoped we could have seen more of it (the ending), but this drama still holds a special place in my heart, and I definitely recommend it!
Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
a simple and fulfilling drama
I'm writing this review after rewatching this drama and I had forgotten how much I loved it.The story is quite simple and a troupe that, if you are used to reading manhwas, you'll have seen a couple times, however, it's still great. Lighthearted and funny with a couple serious and emotional moments that just add to it.
Rowoon's acting here wasn't that great yet, but his character is simple and he has great chemistry with Hye Yoon, although I'm conviced my daughter would have chemistry even with a rock if she wanted to.
Eitherway, this drama is a nice watch, and no-brainer that's totally worth it.
If you've watched and liked lovely runner, you'll probably like this one as well since Hye Yoon's character seems familiar in a way, both dramas have some similar plot lines, like the subtle suspense, two time-lines (although here they'renot simultaneous or affect each other) and of course, the romance! Hye Yoon's character is also just as lively, funny and cute.
To wrap it up, if you're wandering about watching it or not, please do, it might not be the best drama you'll see in your life, but it's surely worth it.
Questa recensione ti è stata utile?