Completo
Sirenas
0 persone hanno trovato utile questa recensione
apr 27, 2024
40 di 40 episodi visti
Completo 0
Generale 6.0
Storia 6.5
Acting/Cast 6.0
Musica 6.0
Valutazione del Rewatch 5.0

Average but charming

It's a good series to watch if you aren't looking for anything that can cause lack of sleep due to wanting to get to the next episode. Having recently getting back into the Asian series mode, I was super excited to see a new Wuxia series with high ratings. However, the series has the same flaws as with many others. The acting of the main protagonists are just slightly less than average and the only saving grace is they have some chemistry with each other. It feels like actors these days are chosen based on looks and less on their ability to act and draw the audience in. The actions scenes were below average and it made me miss again the days when actors with some actual martial arts skills were chosen for these types of roles. The plot had potential but the transitions were choppy.

I did appreciate that the historical costume and makeup weren't as ridiculous as some other series, and nothing was too overly dramatized. And despite it being an overall average, it was still entertaining enough to finish.

Leggi di Più

Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
Droppato 10/40
20_DramaQueen_23
5 persone hanno trovato utile questa recensione
lug 25, 2023
10 di 40 episodi visti
Droppato 0
Generale 5.5
Storia 5.0
Acting/Cast 10
Musica 7.0
Valutazione del Rewatch 4.5
I have seen a few drama series with Cheng Yi in them like:

Stand By Me, Immortal Samsara and Love and Redemption.

He is actually an excellent actor in all three although I appreciated his character, Si Feng, the most - in Love and Redemption.

L&R is still by far my top pick when it comes to Cheng Yi.

I have been waiting weeks and months for the MYSTERIOUS LOTUS CASEBOOK and finally it has been released!

What I like about this one so far (two episodes in) is that it leans more towards epic sword fights, physical battles, lots of action and adventure plus some good story telling rather than a drawn out love story or two which ruins it each and every time for me. 1%-5% is fine, but that is about it! However, this isn't original, especially if you have seen other dramas with murder cases being looked into and ultimately solved.

In this one I wonder if it is Cheng Yi's real voice being used rather than a voice over - if it is dubbed over I prefer the person that did it in L & R. However, it isn't too bad even if it is Yi's own natural voice, but whoever did it for the character of Si Feng had the best voice ever.

With most dramas it seems it is normal to start out great for the first 10-15/20 episodes, lag in the middle then pick up again for the last 10 or so episodes. Mind you, I didn't find that with L & R or Ashes Of Love probably because they were my first real C Dramas.

I'm hoping that MLC is going to be just as good and hope it will remain interesting throughout without too many boring moments.

I believe this is meant to be more Wuxia style than Xianxia so there is a strong chance it will deliver 100% as long as there aren't too many weak females in distress with annoying high pitched voices or overdone cliches.

Currently, Cheng Yi in this drama series is nothing like his other characters except maybe one. I'm sure as each episode unfolds there will be more to him than meets the eye.

Have watched 8 episodes now and although I like it - it isn't one of Cheng Yi's BEST drama series at all nor is it going to be one I'd rewatch compared to others.

32 episodes to go!

Made it to Episode 10 and don't know if I will continue - this is most definitely not Cheng Yi's greatest choice when it comes to dramas. His acting is fine, but he reminds me of another actor who played a very similar role. That actor was Li Hong Yi in The Blood Of Youth.

This would have been somewhat tolerable had it stayed with the three main males rather than bringing in an old love interest from the past, also, if Cheng Yi's character had more charisma and exceptional fighting techniques rather than a mere shadow of his former self with no fighting abilities whatsoever.

Cheng Yi needs to find another role like Si Feng only more Wuxia than Xianxia with little romance - bromance is fine!

Leggi di Più

Questa recensione ti è stata utile?
The Lotus Casebook (2023) poster

Dettagli

Statistiche

  • Puteggio: 9.0 (segnato da 7,374 utenti)
  • Classificato: #51
  • Popolarità: #899
  • Chi Guarda: 19,688

Collaboratori Top

116 modifiche
60 modifiche
53 modifiche
53 modifiche

Liste Popolari

Liste collegate degli utenti
Who is Your Favourite Cdrama Couple? ❣
320 titles 4432 voters 322 loves 74
Best Wuxia or Xianxia drama
151 titles 1511 voters 266 loves 16
Best of the Best - Drama Edition (CLOSED)
104 titles 1501 voters 81 loves 25

Visto di Recente Da