Meteor Garden (2018)

A car crash that I can't look away from

I've been wanting to watch a Chinese drama for quite some time and I just picked this one cause it was pretty famous. When I saw it was an adaptation of the same story of Boys Over Flowers I was ready to just give up right then and there, cause that drama is terrible and super problematic, but I didn't have any other thing to watch so I just gave it a chance and it's not as bad as I thought?

Honestly there were very few scenes of bullying that got me super irritated and where very unnecessary. Shancai and Si mostly just bickered back and forth and that was entertaining enough and created the tension needed. The writers could've just made the initial misunderstanding and made the both leads argue a lot and dislike each other. There was no need for Si to humiliate her in public or harass her, but since those scenes were scarce I managed to look past them and not drop this drama.

Aside problematic stuff, this drama has many issues. The story is pretty ordinary and full of clichés. You can tell the writers ran out of creativity to stretch the plot for 49 episodes cause they repeat the same plot line at least four times. I was just glad there was no amnesia plot in the end because I think I wouldn't be able to bear that.

Since there were so many episodes the drama could've explored the supporting characters much better than in Korean dramas, but they just ended up shoving characters that no one cares about in the story and making boring ships instead. Also the characters in this drama are always doing terrible stuff, never apologize and somehow are forgiven anyway.

Also, I've heard that Chinese dramas are dubbed over for some reason and that gave me a major whiplash. The dubbing is so artificial that initially I couldn't focus while watching, but I eventually got used to it. I guess another thing that I got used to was the poor acting in this. Seriously, almost all actors do a mediocre job in this, although I think I could give some credit to Dylan Wang and Shen Yue. I don't know about her, but I'd heard Dylan was still a fairly new actor and that Daoming Si was his first major role and I can say that he compensated his lack of experience with a very natural chemistry with the other actors and a lot of charisma. Many times him and Shen Yue seemed to be legit having fun while acting and I appreciate that. He also made me grow fond of Si, whom I hated in the beginning so props to him.

The music is also meh. I feel like most times the songs they used didn't really feel like were fit for the scenes, however I really loved River by Bishop Briggs.

I liked Shancai in the beginning, she actually stood up for herself, but with time she just became the bland and annoying female lead, like what happens with "strong" FLs in most dramas so I wasn't surprised. She was constantly meddling other people's business and I have to say she was probably the worst girlfriend I've seen in dramaland. She put little to no effort in her relationship for the majority of the runtime of this drama. I never thought I'd sympathize with Si so much, but the dude moved heaven and hell to be with her while most times she just brushed him off or started joking about it. And the worst thing is that the other characters acted as if it was Si's fault for not being persistent enough, when he was confessing and getting rejected/ignored right and left to the point I was convinced he had no self-respect left. Honestly, most of the time I was unsure if Si's friends (specially Lei) were trying to help him or sabotage him.

The last couple of episodes were super underwhelming and full of unnecessary flashbacks. That wedding scene was one of the biggest "????????" moments I've had while watching dramas. I think the writers should've just erased all of the flashbacks and just focused in showing more of Sancai and Si.

Nonetheless, watching Shancai and Si's love story was pretty entertaining and for the most part of this show I was totally hooked. As I said they have a lot of chemistry and they have a nice balance of fluffy, romantic scenes (although some are TOO cheesy) and angsty scenes. Even though Meteor Garden wasn't the best technically, it's still worth it if you have nothing else to watch and are in the mood for some romance.

Leggi di Più

honestly when i first finished watching this drama, i thought it was great. however after watching a few other chinese dramas, i found this one of the worst among them. it’s still funny and the actors looked good but there’s others more worth your time.
first of all, the ending was really bad and confusing. i didn’t get what was happening at all. they had 49 episodes which i thought was pretty long for these kind of dramas but their ending felt so rushed and not properly planned.
second, they kept replaying many earlier scenes which i felt was too excessive and unnecessary as they could have just cut down on the number of episodes.
third, i’ll say this drama is alright for beginners as it’s dubbed and the chinese is very simple, but there are many others more worth watching where you can learn different lessons, but if you’re the kind who likes a rom-com then you can give this a try.

Leggi di Più

How did I end up here?

After 2 years of suffering I managed to finish this masterpiece of a show.
I consider myself a lover of soapy trashy cliché shows, but this....this was something else. At the beginning of the show I liked it very much it was dramatic and weird (in a good way). But as the show progressed I couldn't stand the songs anymore!!!! It was soooo repetitive and some of the storylines were soooo unrelated to the main plot it was incredible. But the thing that really broke me inside....was the last episode. As I said it took me 2 years and what I get is this.
But to be totally honest I love lei so much, he was the only reason I could stand coming back to this show after very long breaks. The acting was a burning disaster and I'm not going to mention the cinematography. The special effect were horrible, and the cuts were random.
In conclusion, I have so much to say about this show, but I'm too shocked to actually put in into words. Please watch it, just to fully understand my emotional damage.
P.S the damage is not because the plot was good or emotional.

Leggi di Più

I feel really gifted to be able to watch Dylan Wang (Dao Ming Si) in the first Drama he acted in. His mother and father are blessed to give birth to a very talented son! What a great actor. He did excellent playing the character “Si”. Shen Yue (Dong Shan Cai), I felt this wasn’t the right role for her, don’t get me wrong, but I really didn’t see any chemistry between her and Dylan Wang. There was a little bit toward the end but that’s it. I loved her in “Mr. Bad”, she became more experienced in her acting skills after her role in Meteor Gardens and it was her third role in a drama. Darren Chen (Hua Ze Lei), where was he all this time… I need to see more of him. He is of perfection besides Dylan Wang. Caesar Wu (Xi Men Yan) is excellent! Leon Leong (Feng Mei Zuo) is very good.

The storyline was cute. Again, Dylan Wang’s wardrobe I loved. I love that roughness in clothes. Wardrobes for CW and LL were also great. The young girl's wardrobe could’ve been better. The visuals were okay. Thanking the team for bringing this story for public viewing.

Leggi di Più

Fabulous-worth the watch

I came across this drama by accident, this is my first ever C Drama ---- I had previously watched the Korean version. Frankly, I preferred the C- Drama version much much more. The story twists brought in this C- drama was much better than the K version. Dao Ming Si (Dylan W) & Shan Cai (Shen Yue)- the lead pair is absolutely adorable, just epic, one of my all time favourite couple...the looks Dao Ming Si gives her, his character comes as a very confident, passionate, fiery yet so innocent (like a man-child), both of them gave an excellent performances.

This drama had everything romance, love, angst, trust, friendship separation, sacrifice - all elements were there in exact right amount... F4 (Dylan Wang, Darren Chen, Ceaser Wu & Leon Leong) was so cool, all them gave wonderful & memorable performances- wouldn't mind having them at my Uni.

I specially liked Hua Zai Lei's (Darren Chen) character - calm, caring, composed yet intense. Its hard to actually determine whether he genuinely liked Shen Cai and gave her up for Dao Ming Si, at some points I felt like that - he certainly is Shen Cai's guardian angel, always there for her. His story too remained unfinished.

Ceaser Wu's character Xi Men was so suave and sophisticated - wouldn't have minded a bit more screen time on his love story. Leon Leong's character Mei Zuo was ever so charming and delightful too bad the one he fell in love left him and he was all alone (during the meteor shower) at the new year...

This is a great watch, would highly recommend.

Leggi di Più

Not for everyone

I like this show but I just like show because of the actors. There are a lot of thing I don't like about the show

my review is mostly why I don't like the show

Story:
I already watched Korean and Japanese version before watching this show, So I already know the story but there are a lot of changed in this show ( mainly because of Chinese censorship i think )

*spoiler*

-The main story where the 4 boys play game changed into card game.
-Male lead seem so aggressive. in some episode he is very aggressive to Female lead, one time he even kissed FL without her permission but this is how F4 character should be. (main thing why I am not really into this show )
-story doesn't bring the whole thing where the ML become good person but it seem like he change little bit.
if you are into possessive boyfriend type (not for me). This is good to watch but if you like more chill and realistic type of romance, This is not the best. This show is not definitely not chill vibe.

acting:
I don't really have big dislike with their acting but sometime it's little bit overacting. Cast did great job

Music:
There only one thing I dislike about music part is
"say something " .Music is not the best but not bad.

Rewatch value:
depend on you!

overall:
I don't have big dislike with other thing but the story. Story is very important. That's why I give this 6.5

hope this helpful to you.

Leggi di Più

I've been following the development of this version since May 2017. Its been a long time coming since they announced the cast last November and finished filming last spring. However, it was definitely worth it and I fully enjoyed the two months it took to air. I'm gonna miss it now that it is over.

This version probably has the most care put into it. Angie Chai, who also produced the original 'Meteor Garden', was very careful about adapting it to a millennial audience while staying true to the manga. It shows. 'Meteor Garden' (2018) by far covers the manga's plot better than all of the others. This is both a good and bad thing. It allows the character's to fully develop, but feels kinda draggy towards the end (the manga has the same effect). It is 49 episodes long after all.

I loved the chemistry between the leads, Dylan Wang and Shen Yue. All of the supporting characters were enjoyable, though some were better than others (>_< ugh Caina). Like the other adaptations before it, this version has its good points and bad points. It's inevitable that 'Meteor Garden' (2018) will be ruthlessly compared to the other versions. I suggest to all fans to check it out since you'll probably like it if you give it a shot.

Leggi di Più

Everyone knows the story that this is based on but I think the story itself is a little out dated to be remade.

My main issue with the story is the moral ambiguity of the main characters and their actions.
Take one of the first episodes, for example when Dao Ming Si forces himself on Shancai. She is assaulted by him, is very upset afterwards and then she writes him off lightly as a pervert.

I don't think these kind of actions should have a place on TV today.

Further, the shows feeds the idea that it's okay to be treated badly by someone who likes you, for them to treat everyone around badly as long as they make it up with grand gestures.

The actors did their best with the plot and script they were given - for many of the actors, they do not have too many previous credits but are all very watchable.

Overall, the show is toxic. Seeing people fawn over the Dao Ming Si character is worrying - people are buying into the emotional abusive relationship that is shown in the show and writing off what could have been a nice relationship between Shancai and Hua Ze Lei.

I get that people may say, well it's fiction and show be taken with a grain of salt but a show this popular with as many brand advertisements should not be spreading such a message in my opinion.

The only redeeming feature of this show is the random shots of Darren Chen's face throughout the episodes but unfortunately they couldn't help get through 50 episodes only 31..

Leggi di Più

Uma das piores obras da existência e não existência, o próprio conceito de desgraça está na obra e pode até ser considerado a obra em si, personagens horríveis, o MC por um motivo fútil, apenas porque era destratado na infância pela irmã e não recebia amorzinho dos pais, mesmo sendo ultra mega rico, achava que podia tratar os outros como lixo, e passa a série como um babaca, agressor de mulher, otário e tudo de ruim com a protagonista e no final, a que foi humilhada por ele, por várias vezes, fica com ele.

Linda lição, seja otário, mude e você terá seu final happy ou seja, você terá sua recompensa.

Não seja otário, seja uma boa pessoa, esteja com a pessoa, escute ela, seja um ombro amigo e no fim a única coisa que você irá toma é no cu.

Leggi di Più

Meteor Garden 2018

Here's my review on Meteor Garden Remake 2018.
I love the original story because of it's depth, simplicity and story telling which the remake couldn't reach at some level. It is still a great series and somehow it ended way better than the original. It has great drama mixed with comedy and action. It is also considerably more fun. The lasting iconic moments also resurfaces in the series. I have reservations about the directing of the original series. Like for instance, when Dao Ming Si was punching a certain character multiple times there was no sign of brusing on his face. On the remake, the directing was better but I guess some scenes was still better depicted in the original. Like, Dao Ming Si getting beat up was more dramatic in the original.
On a good note, I like the casting choice especially Dylan Wang as Dao ming Si and Shen Yue as Dong Shancai. It felt like they were a real couple based on their acting. I also with like to point out that the progression of the initimacy between Shancai and Dao Ming Si is more convincing. I also love the additional characters point of view because it diverts the attention of people who are already familiar with the Original story. Also, their are point of views that is far too long to get into.
It is a great remake because the writers added more thrill compared to the thrilling scene in the original where it's going back and forth. The visuals are also more authentic and creative. Overall, I love how it ended. I still have great respect to the Original Series but since the series is also produced by the Original's writer Angie Chai it still holds a great story telling.

Leggi di Più

I love this drama¡¡¡

Estuve leyendo las reseñas de otros usuarios, especialmente las negativas, muchos conocedores dicen que es uno de los mas fieles al manga pero con una historia muy diluida e infantil, pues bien aunque solo he visto el anime, y la version coreana de BOF, creo que es una excelente versión acorde al publico que buscaban enganchar: por Dios¡ es un drama juvenil de chicos universitarios... es obvio que habrá cosas tontas y eso me gusta porque cuando jovenes nuestra vision del amor es muy limitada: nos gustan los chicos por como se visten, como nos tratan, los lugares que frecuentamos, su grupo de amigos, por ser geniales e inteligentes, por tener aspiraciones, por nuestra conexion con ellos y eso es algo que fluye y fluye como un rio entre los protagonistas, y sus amigos, el amor mas profundo es mas comun con la madurez de los años, y de hecho me sorprendio agradablemente la forma en que Ah si se enamora de Shan cai, creo que es el tipo de hombre que se enamora una sola vez en la vida, son pocos, pero existen y él es su gran representante, eso hace que la historia transcienda y nos haga querer un amor asi, aunque las expectadoras seamos de 30 o 40 jajaja. Por otro lado, el triangulo amoroso no es nada falso, particularmente cuando estuve en la escuela siempre me gustaban los mismos chicos que le gustaban a mi mejor amiga, pero el chico solo puede elegir a 1, y la otra si es verdadera amiga, debe desear lo mejor, en esta serie naturalmente Shan cai gusta primero de Lei, porque es gentil, apuesto y talentoso, mientras Ah si, es orgulloso y de mal caracter, pero a diferencia de Lei, para Ah si, Shan cai no es algo pasajero, realmente se enamoró de ella y hará hasta lo imposible para que ella se enamore de él.

Algo que me gustó mucho del drama es que los dialogos son naturales, realmente hay dramas en que el chico para confesar su amor da un discurso digno de un premio literario, y particularmente no me gusta, porque no es común, lo natural es que las personas expresemos nuestros sentimientos desde nuestras ilusiones, incluso desde nuestros temores, desde nuestro caracter, y Ah si es genial en eso, cuando está con Shan cai es torpe y dulce a la vez porque enfrenta sentimientos que nunca habia sentido, sabe mostrarse inseguro consigo mismo ante el rechazo de Shan cai y solo una pequeña muestra de amor de ella es capaz de devolverle las fuerzas de luchar por lo que siente. Sus amigos se preocupan porque ven lo infantil y mal geniado que puede llegar a ser, ellos al ser expertos en el amor saben que esas actitudes son repelentes para cualquier chica normal, pero definitivamente Shan cai no es normal, sabe ser empática con Ah Si, ponerse en su lugar y conectar con él, wao¡ me encanta como ella descubre que poco a poco está enamorada hasta llegar al punto de contagiarse de su firmeza para defender su relacion ante la madre de Ah Si.

Si estas pensando en ver este drama, no te llenes de expecativas irreales, es un drama juvenil que habla del amor sincero, la amistad, la primera vez que te rompen el corazon, ....

PD. Y los que sienten que el hecho de que no exista la persecucion inicial que Daoming si hace contra Shan Cai, la tarjeta roja, el bullying sistematico que existe en la escuela y como solo 4 chicos puede pasar por encima de maestros y todo el sistema escolar, relajense¡ creo que los chicos de las escuelas actuales dificilmente pueden identificarse con un sistema tan cruel, en esta epoca con todas las redes sociales todo lo que Ah si hubiera hecho contra Shan Cai se habria expandido como polvora, ganandose el repudio de todo un publico, por favor Ah Si es de mal caracter pero sabe ser un caballero, y eso me encanta

Leggi di Più

El mejor remake sin duda

De todos los dramas que visto este es el que mas me ha trasmitido, tiene tanto comedia, romance y drama. Por un lado, la trama es igual que la de todas las versiones pero al tener 49 capítulos se profundiza mas en ciertos aspectos y puedes entender mas a los personajes. Los personajes secundarios tmb me han gustado mucho.El OST es precioso y hace que las escenas sean mas emocionantes o dramaticas cosa que adoro. Ademas las actaciones son increible, simplemente con las miradas consiguen tranmitir muchisimo. El resumen, lo recomiendo muchisimo, a mi los cdramas me suelen parecer aburridos pero este me ha robado el corazon. De todas formas creo q es un drama para no ver de golpe sino ir disfrutando de cada capitulo y tener paciencia ya que hay cosas que ponen de los nervios

Leggi di Più